Masoud Rahimi Bin Mehrzad v Public Prosecutor

Court of Appeal

[2024] SGCA 56 · CA/OAC 2/2024 · cites 11 cases · cited by 5 cases

The question

Is there a right to file a second clemency petition after the first is rejected?

The answer

No. The Court of Appeal held there is no right to file a second clemency petition once the first is rejected, found no justification to stay the execution, and dismissed the application summarily.

Step 1: What happened

Mr Masoud Rahimi bin Mehrzad was a prisoner awaiting capital punishment. He was convicted in the High Court in 2013 of possessing not less than 31.14g of diamorphine for the purposes of trafficking and received the mandatory death sentence on 19 October 2015. His defence at trial was that he had no knowledge of the drugs and had been framed by an illegal moneylending syndicate, in particular by a man he called "Alf". The trial judge and the Court of Appeal rejected that account, relying on his notebook entries and text messages referring to drugs. His appeal was dismissed on 10 October 2016 and a clemency petition was rejected on 5 July 2019. He then took part in many post-appeal applications, including CM 50, an application to review his appeal that was dismissed on 1 August 2024.

On 15 November 2024 the President ordered his execution for 29 November 2024. On 27 November 2024 he filed OAC No 2 of 2024 in the Court of Appeal, seeking a stay of execution and permission to make a post-appeal application in a capital case (a PACC application). He relied on three grounds: a fresh clemency petition filed on 22 November 2024 after the Court of Appeal in CA 30 granted declarations that the Attorney-General had committed a breach of confidence over his correspondence; a complaint he lodged with the Law Society against his former counsel in CM 50; and what he said was new evidence, namely a statutory declaration from his step-sister and the intended testimony of a man known as "Arab". A single judge of the Court of Appeal dealt with the application.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether a further clemency petition entitled the applicant to a stay of execution
  2. Whether the pending Law Society complaint against his former counsel justified a stay
  3. Whether the evidence of his step-sister and of Arab gave a PACC or review application a reasonable prospect of success

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the first ground, the Registry had been told that morning that the President would not exercise the clemency power on the further petition, so the death sentence stood. The court agreed with the Prosecution that there is no right to file a second clemency petition once the first is rejected, and so no right to a further period to take advice. In CM 50 the Court of Appeal had already held that the disclosed correspondence could not have affected the convictions; the earliest disclosure of his correspondence was on 30 January 2019, long after his conviction and appeal. The ground had no reasonable prospect of success.

On the second ground, counsel's discharge in CM 50 had been considered and found justified by the Court of Appeal, so there had been no misleading of Mr Masoud or the court. The same counsel continued to act for him in other matters until 16 October 2024, yet the complaint was lodged only on 11 November 2024. The court saw the complaint as an attempt to delay the sentence, and any sanction against counsel would not touch the integrity of the conviction.

On the third ground, Mr Masoud had not explained what he did to find his step-sister for the trial or appeal. Her evidence could at most show that Alf existed and had some working relationship with him, not that it extended to drugs. His conviction rested on strong evidence of knowledge in his notebook and phone, and his set-up claim had been rejected because he was not a credible witness and raised it late, not because Alf was absent. The new evidence would not affect the conviction, sentence or appeal.

From the judgment

“I agree with the Prosecution’s contentions that there is certainly no right to file a second or any subsequent petitions for clemency once the PACP’s first petition has been rejected by the President.”

[2024] SGCA 56 at [66]

Step 4: The order

The court dismissed the application summarily without an oral hearing under s 60G(8) of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1969, finding no justification to stay the execution and no basis to grant permission to file a PACC application or an application for permission to review.

Terms in this case

Stay of execution
A court order that temporarily stops a judgment or order from being enforced, often while an appeal is pending. Filing an appeal does not by itself stop enforcement. In a criminal case, a sentence of imprisonment or a fine can also be stayed pending an appeal.
Review application
An application under the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 asking an appellate court to reopen its own earlier decision in a criminal matter. It needs the court's permission, generally only one is allowed per decision, and the applicant must show new and compelling material indicating a miscarriage of justice.

Court record

Key facts

Court Court of Appeal
Decided
Judge Tay Yong Kwang
What the case was about Criminal Procedure and Sentencing

Source: [2024] SGCA 56, Court of Appeal, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

Counsel

Counsel for the respondent

Statutes cited

Cases cited (11)

SLR (8)
  • [2017] 1 SLR 257
  • [2022] 2 SLR 1018
  • [2022] 4 SLR 934
  • [2024] 1 SLR 1127
  • [2024] 1 SLR 414
  • [2024] 1 SLR 677
  • [2024] 4 SLR 331
  • [2024] 5 SLR 1290

Cited by (5)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA 56)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer