Public Prosecutor v Adam bin Mohamed Noor

High Court

[2024] SGHC 25 · HC/MA 9071/2023/01 · cites 3 cases

The question

Can the person in charge of electrical works be liable when unsupervised workers touch a re-energised cable?

The answer

Yes. Allowing the prosecution's appeal, the High Court found the cable was dead when work began and later re-energised from the substation, convicted him of negligently failing to ensure it stayed de-energised, and imposed ten months' imprisonment.

Step 1: What happened

Adam bin Mohamed Noor was a technical officer with SP PowerGrid Ltd and the authorised person in charge of low-voltage works for the decommissioning of a substation at Kranji. On 24 September 2017 he unlocked an overground box near the substation, inserted network links into one unit and removed them from Unit 4, which was fed by the cable to be decommissioned. He allowed the workers to remove the flimsy doors and then left with a colleague, Fharouk, for the substation, leaving the box unattended. Mr Asogan, a director of the subcontractor, removed the bolts securing the cable cores and handled the metal lugs with bare hands; he was electrocuted and died. SP PowerGrid later pleaded guilty to its own charge under the Workplace Safety and Health Act.

The accused was charged under s 15(3A) of the Act with negligently allowing the workers to work unsupervised on a de-energised cable without ensuring it stayed de-energised. The prosecution said he had tested the cable, found it dead and told the workers they could start. The accused said he had told them not to start because the cable was still live, and that the deceased began on his own. The District Judge acquitted him, finding it unproven that the cable was ever de-energised and preferring the accused's account, which Fharouk supported. The prosecution appealed in Magistrate's Appeal No 9071 of 2023.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the District Judge erred in finding it unproven that the cable was de-energised when the deceased began work.
  2. Whether the District Judge erred in preferring the accused's and Fharouk's evidence that the workers were told not to start work.
  3. Whether the prosecution proved that the accused failed to ensure the cable remained de-energised.
  4. What sentence was appropriate if the accused was convicted.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the first issue, the court held that the charge did not require proof of exactly when and how the cable was de-energised, and the District Judge had placed undue weight on that question. Only the accused or Fharouk had access to the fuse in the substation, so both were interested witnesses whose accounts called for caution. The prosecution's case did not rest mainly on the regulator's report but on the workers' evidence: a voltage meter reading said to show "000", a test lamp that did not light, a flick test that revealed no current, no sparks from the impact wrench, and the deceased bending the cable cores for a few moments without immediate shock. Taken together, this proved beyond reasonable doubt that the cable was initially dead.

On the second issue, the workers' accounts were materially consistent; small differences about who the accused spoke to were understandable for events about four years earlier. The removal of the concrete slab, panels and doors showed work had gone beyond identifying the cable. The accused was not candid: he denied knowing or speaking to the deceased, contrary to several witnesses, and was evasive about a caution sticker on Unit 4 of the low-voltage board despite years with the company.

On the third issue, since the cable was dead when work began, it must have been re-energised afterwards for the deceased to be electrocuted, and only someone in the substation could have done that. A worker's evidence of seeing someone look out of the substation supported this, though the prosecution did not have to prove how it happened.

On sentence, applying Mao Xuezhong, both sides accepted that harm was high and culpability moderate. The court placed culpability at the higher end of the moderate range because of several breaches of the company's procedures, and rejected the accused's continued claim that he had told the workers not to start.

From the judgment

“The Deceased’s unfortunate electrocution made it patently clear that the decommissioning of the Incident Cable was an inherently high-risk activity.”

[2024] SGHC 25 at [59]

Step 4: The order

The High Court allowed the prosecution's appeal against acquittal, convicted the accused of the charge under s 15(3A) of the Workplace Safety and Health Act, and sentenced him to ten months' imprisonment. It found it unnecessary to decide whether an amended charge should have been framed.

Terms in this case

Acquittal
The formal outcome of a criminal case in which the accused is found not guilty of, or discharged in a way amounting to an acquittal of, a charge. A person acquitted cannot be tried again for the same offence unless the acquittal is overturned by a higher court, for example on a prosecution appeal.
Beyond reasonable doubt
The standard of proof in a criminal case: the prosecution must prove every element of the charge so that no reasonable doubt about guilt remains. A reasonable doubt leads to an acquittal.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Vincent Hoong
What the case was about Criminal Procedure and Sentencing, Criminal Law

Source: [2024] SGHC 25, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

Counsel

Counsel for the respondent
Counsel for the appellant

Statutes cited

Cases cited (3)

SG (1)
  • [2023] SGDC 133
SLR (2)
  • [2020] 2 SLR 533
  • [2020] 5 SLR 580

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 25)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer