Khan Aisanullah v Rajib Kumar Dhali
[2024] SGHC 313 · HC/S 977/2021 · cites 14 cases (9 Singapore, 5 foreign) · cited by 1 case
Can a sole shareholder sue a nominee director for losses that are really the company's?
No. The High Court found the nominee director breached the oral agreement but owed no fiduciary duties, and held the reflective loss principle barred the pleaded losses, so it dismissed the claim and the counterclaim.
Step 1: What happened
Mr Khan Aisanullah, the plaintiff, lives in India. Around 26 November 2019 he bought Secur Credentials Logistics & Services Pte Ltd and became its sole shareholder. Understanding that a Singapore company needed a locally resident director, he appointed Mr Rajib Kumar Dhali, the defendant, as a director alongside himself. It was undisputed that the two made an oral agreement around 14 December 2019, but they disputed its terms: the plaintiff said the defendant was only a nominee director doing simple administrative tasks for a one-time fee of S$4,000, while the defendant said he was a full director entitled to a monthly salary of US$5,000 and other benefits.
In January 2021 the defendant lodged a form with ACRA stating that the plaintiff had resigned as director, which the defendant accepted was untrue; applied to OCBC to replace the plaintiff on the company's bank account; transferred all the plaintiff's shares to himself without consideration or consent; and changed the company's address, activity and name. On 17 March 2021 he applied to strike the company off. Around 29 January 2021, clients had paid US$310,435.00 into the account, and the balance on 24 January 2021 was US$87,146.22. The account was later closed. In Suit No 977 of 2021 the plaintiff sued for breach of the oral agreement and breach of fiduciary duty, pleading loss by diminution in the value of his 100% shareholding. The defendant, who acted in person, denied withdrawing money, said the plaintiff had used the company for illegal activities, and counterclaimed for a year's salary, lost income and S$500,000 for "trauma and harassment".
Step 2: What the court had to decide
- Whether the oral agreement made the defendant only a nominee director, and whether he owed the plaintiff fiduciary duties
- Whether the defendant breached the oral agreement, and whether the plaintiff's claim was barred by illegality
- Whether the reflective loss principle prevented the plaintiff from recovering the pleaded losses
- Whether the defendant's counterclaim succeeded
Step 3: How the court reasoned
The court accepted the plaintiff's version of the agreement. The defendant had no relevant qualifications, the two were strangers, the business was never discussed, he conceded he would just follow the plaintiff's instructions and did no work for the company before January 2021, and he admitted the claimed salary did not seem a legitimate offer. The evidence did not show how much, if anything, the defendant withdrew from the account, and the court made no finding on that.
As a nominee the defendant was an agent, but applying Susilawati v American Express Bank Ltd [2009] 2 SLR(R) 737, his role was limited to simple administrative tasks while the plaintiff kept sole control of the account, so the plaintiff was not peculiarly vulnerable to him and no fiduciary duties arose. By removing the plaintiff as director, taking his shares, altering the company's details, striking it off and taking over the account, the defendant breached the agreement.
The illegality defence, which the defendant never expressly pleaded, failed under the approach in Ting Siew May v Boon Lay Choo and another [2014] 3 SLR 609: the bank statement and bank correspondence did not show that the plaintiff intended to break the law when the agreement was made. Even had there been wrongdoing, the defendant should have reported it or brought a derivative action rather than seize the company.
All the pleaded losses were the company's losses or losses to the plaintiff as shareholder. Following Miao Weiguo v Tendcare Medical Group Holdings Pte Ltd [2022] 1 SLR 884 and an English Court of Appeal decision, an independent contractual claim did not avoid the principle unless the loss was separate and distinct, and it was not. The company having been struck off did not matter, since the principle is a rule of company law rather than a rule against double recovery, and the company could still be restored within the six-year period. The court said the proper course was to restore the company so that it could sue.
The counterclaim failed because the defendant's version of the agreement was rejected, he did not prove the S$4,000 fee was unpaid, and the plaintiff owed him no fiduciary duties.
“While I sympathise with the Plaintiff’s predicament, shareholders cannot enjoy the benefits of the corporate form, including limited liability, without also assuming its disadvantages”
[2024] SGHC 313 at [70]
Step 4: The order
The High Court dismissed the plaintiff's claim and also dismissed the defendant's counterclaim in its entirety. It found that the defendant breached the oral agreement but owed no fiduciary duties, and that the reflective loss principle barred recovery of the losses pleaded. Costs were to be heard later.
Terms in this case
- Fiduciary duty
- A duty of loyalty owed by a person who has undertaken to act for another in a relationship of trust and confidence, such as a trustee, company director or agent. It requires acting in good faith, not profiting from the position without consent and avoiding conflicts of interest.
- Breach of contract
- A failure, without lawful excuse, to perform a contractual obligation as and when it is due. Every breach gives the innocent party a right to damages; a sufficiently serious breach may also allow it to end the contract.
- Illegality
- The doctrine under which a court may refuse to enforce a contract, or to allow a claim, where the contract or its performance involves breaking a statute or is contrary to public policy. Whether money or property already transferred can be recovered depends on further rules.
- Counterclaim
- A claim that a defendant brings against the claimant in the same proceedings, rather than starting a separate action. The court can decide the claim and the counterclaim together.
Court record
Key facts
| Court | High Court |
|---|---|
| Decided | |
| Judge | Chan Seng Onn |
| What the case was about | Contract, Equity, Companies |
Source: [2024] SGHC 313, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .
Judge
- Chan Seng Onn Delivered the judgment
Parties
- Khan Aisanullah Plaintiff
- Rajib Kumar Dhali Defendant
Counsel
Statutes cited
Cases cited (14)
- Axis Megalink Sdn Bhd and another v Far East Mining Pte Ltd [2024] SGHC(A) 15
- [2021] SGHC 117
- [2009] 2 SLR(R) 737
- [2014] 3 SLR 609
- [2018] 2 SLR 655
- [2021] 5 SLR 477
- [2022] 1 SLR 884
- [2023] 2 SLR 235
- [2024] 4 SLR 1760
- [1950] 1 KB 359
- [2012] EWHC 3727
- [2015] EWHC 3220
- [2021] AC 39
- [2022] EWCA Civ 1943
Cited by (1)
Related cases
Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.
-
Are former employees liable for breach of confidence for keeping an employer's confidential files after leaving?
High Court · 23 January 2025 · [2025] SGHC 13 -
Can a company summarily dismiss its chief executive for vulgar emails to staff and confidentiality breaches?
High Court · 14 October 2024 · [2024] SGHC 260 -
Would a court restrain a share issue approved by only half of a company's directors?
High Court · 22 September 2025 · [2025] SGHC 190 -
Are losses from employees' lawfully given notice caused by breaches committed only once they join a competitor?
High Court (Appellate Division) · 9 September 2025 · [2025] SGHC(A) 17 -
Can an investor still sue in 2020 over a fiduciary's ending of his stake by November 2007?
High Court (Appellate Division) · 1 July 2025 · [2025] SGHC(A) 8 -
Does a group chief executive's duty to manage associated businesses include managing their closure?
High Court (Appellate Division) · 26 July 2023 · [2023] SGHC(A) 26
Referenced in
Statutes interpreted in this judgment
Read the full judgment
The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.
Read on eLitigationSource: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 313)
This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer