Envy Asset Management Pte. Ltd. (In Liquidation) and others v Lau Lee Sheng and others

High Court

[2024] SGHC 38 · HC/OC 193/2022 ( HC/RA 243/2023 ) · cites 13 cases (12 Singapore, 1 foreign) · cited by 2 cases

The question

Should a liquidators' claim be struck out because its figures may count internal account transfers?

The answer

No. The High Court held the claim disclosed a reasonable cause of action, as the transferred money might later have left the companies or the defendants might have been enriched, and the method was for trial; it dismissed the appeal.

Step 1: What happened

On the background set out for this application, Envy Asset Management Pte Ltd purported from early 2016 to early 2020 to trade nickel, with investors entering Letters of Agreement for a return of principal plus profits. It emerged that the trading did not exist and that earlier investors were paid out of later investors' funds. The Envy companies were wound up, and their liquidators brought Originating Claim No 193 of 2022 against former employees who had also invested, seeking to claw back the so-called Overwithdrawn Sums, being fictitious profits paid to them out of other investors' money. The claims were for transactions defrauding creditors, transactions at an undervalue, unfair preferences and unjust enrichment. The liquidators computed the sums using a running account of all inflows and outflows in each defendant's trading account.

The first and second defendants applied to strike out the claim for the Overwithdrawn Sums, objecting that the running account counted internal transfers from their accounts to other investors' accounts. On the claimants' own case such transfers involved no money leaving the companies, so, the defendants argued, they could not be clawed back; without them, the claim against the first defendant would be negative. An assistant registrar refused the application. On appeal in Registrar's Appeal No 243 of 2023 the defendants also asked, for the first time, for the claimants to be directed to amend their pleadings to state that they were not claiming the internal transfers.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the claim for the Overwithdrawn Sums should be struck out under O 9 r 16(1) of the Rules of Court 2021 because the running account included internal transfers.
  2. Whether the three grounds for striking out in O 9 r 16(1) can be treated as one.
  3. Whether the claimants should be ordered to amend their pleadings to disclaim the internal transfers.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The court stressed that striking out is reserved for plainly unsustainable claims, and that the grounds in O 9 r 16(1) are distinct alternatives. A claim that discloses no reasonable cause of action is not automatically an abuse of process, which concerns matters such as a claimant knowingly pursuing a case doomed to fail; counsel should state which limb they rely on. Treating the application as one under limb (a), the claim disclosed a reasonable cause of action. The internally transferred money might later have left the companies, and even if it had not, the defendants might still have received consideration or been enriched, for example by nominating third parties to receive the transfers; these were matters for trial. The claimants had pleaded the facts at length with a line-by-line account, and their affidavit evidence defined the Overwithdrawn Sums as purported profits paid in excess of principal, so the defendants knew the case to meet. The complaint was really about methodology, which is for trial. Striking out every reference to the Overwithdrawn Sums would also be overinclusive, since it would remove entries the defendants did not challenge.

The amendment prayer was a fresh point the claimants had little chance to answer. As O 9 r 16(1) governs both striking out and amendment, a reason that failed to justify striking out would generally also fail to justify an ordered amendment.

From the judgment

“In my view, counsel should clearly specify which limb of O 9 r 16 they are invoking, and to particularise their arguments according to the legal standard for that limb.”

[2024] SGHC 38 at [21]

Step 4: The order

The High Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the refusal to strike out, and also dismissed the new prayer for the pleadings to be amended. Costs were to be agreed or decided on written submissions.

Terms in this case

Striking out
A court order removing all or part of a pleading or other document, for example because it discloses no reasonable cause of action, is frivolous or vexatious, or is an abuse of process. It can end a claim or defence without a full trial.
Cause of action
The set of facts that gives a person a legal right to sue another person and ask the court for a remedy, such as a breach of contract or an act of negligence.
Pleadings
The formal written documents in which each party to a civil case sets out the facts it relies on, such as the statement of claim and the defence. They define the issues the court has to decide.
Abuse of process
Use of court proceedings for an improper purpose or in a way that is unfair or oppressive to the other side. The court may strike out or stay proceedings that abuse its process.
Liquidator
A person appointed to wind up a company, usually under the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 or under the law of the company's home jurisdiction, who takes control of its assets, realises them, investigates its affairs, decides creditors' claims and pays them in the order the law sets, passing any surplus to the members.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Goh Yihan
What the case was about Civil Procedure

Source: [2024] SGHC 38, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Statutes cited

Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act
Misrepresentation Act
s 2
Restructuring and Dissolution Act

Cases cited (13)

SLR (9)
  • [1991] 1 SLR(R) 844
  • [1992] 1 SLR(R) 22
  • [1997] 3 SLR(R) 649
  • [2000] 1 SLR(R) 53
  • [2000] 2 SLR(R) 455
  • [2009] 2 SLR(R) 814
  • [2021] 5 SLR 738
  • [2022] 2 SLR 1018
  • [2023] 4 SLR 1133
UK (1)
  • [1965] 1 WLR 1238

Cited by (2)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 38)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer