WZK and another v WZJ

High Court (Family Division)

[2024] SGHCF 39 · HCF/DCA 43/2024 · HCF/DCA 46/2024

The question

Is a later will valid simply because it was the last one made?

The answer

No. The High Court held the court must be satisfied the later will was properly executed, made of sound mind and truly the testator's will, upheld the rejection of the December will, and dismissed both appeals.

Step 1: What happened

A divorced man died on 20 October 2019, leaving three children: an elder daughter (the first defendant), a younger daughter who took no part in the case, and a son (the plaintiff). On 30 May 2017 he had made a will in a Singapore lawyer's office, revoking an earlier will and leaving his estate equally to his three children, with the first defendant as executrix. After a heart attack he lived with the first defendant, and in December 2017 he moved to Johor, Malaysia. The son alleged that the first defendant had asked their father to leave her home, which she denied; the trial judge made no finding on this.

After the death a will dated 28 December 2017 surfaced. It named the second defendant, a friend of the first defendant who had cared for the deceased in Malaysia, as executrix, and left the estate to the first defendant's two children. The second defendant testified that she went with the deceased to a Malaysian lawyer's office to execute it. The deceased's CPF nomination still mirrored the May will. After an eight-day trial the District Judge upheld the May will and declined to replace the first defendant as executor with the plaintiff. The defendants appealed in District Court Appeal No 43 of 2024 and the plaintiff cross-appealed in District Court Appeal No 46 of 2024.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the defendants proved that the December will was the valid last will of the deceased
  2. Whether an adverse inference should be drawn against the plaintiff for not producing the joint handwriting report from the Health Sciences Authority
  3. Whether the first defendant should be removed as executor and replaced by the plaintiff

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The court stressed that a will is not valid merely because it is the latest; the party relying on it, here the first defendant, had to prove due execution, sound mind and that it truly was the testator's will. The reasons offered for a change of heart, such as the son blocking his father on WhatsApp or a dispute over title deeds, did not explain disinheriting the other children, and the unchanged CPF nomination undercut them. The trial judge rightly disbelieved key defence witnesses: the driver who said he witnessed the will broke down, could not identify the family and admitted the Malaysian lawyer drafted his affidavit, while the lawyer kept no signed copy and gave evidence contradicted by the defendants. The first defendant's evidence did not impress either; she applied for probate under the May will yet declined to extract the grant, and on the whole the evidence seemed to suggest the story of the December will was her creation.

On the signature, the experts at trial conflicted and the thumbprint evidence was inconclusive. The plaintiff was entitled to rely on litigation privilege over the joint report, the defendants never applied for it below, and drawing an adverse inference would undermine that privilege. Even if the report went against the plaintiff, the remaining evidence supported the trial judge's findings.

On the cross-appeal, the estate's assets were identified and the grant only needed extracting, so there was no reason to remove the first defendant, who was on notice to perform her duties faithfully.

From the judgment

“A will is not valid by virtue only of it being the last in line.”

[2024] SGHCF 39 at [4]

Step 4: The order

The High Court (Family Division) dismissed both appeals, DCA 43 and DCA 46, leaving the trial judge's findings and orders in place, and directed written submissions on costs within 14 days.

Terms in this case

Executor
A person named in a will to carry out its terms by collecting the deceased's assets, paying debts and expenses, and distributing what remains to the beneficiaries; the executor's authority comes from the will and is confirmed by a grant of probate.
Adverse inference
A conclusion against a party that a court may draw when the party fails, without good reason, to produce evidence, call a witness or give an explanation it could have given, such as that the missing evidence would have been unfavourable to it. Drawing it is discretionary, and the Evidence Act 1893 expressly allows it.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court (Family Division)
Decided
Judge Choo Han Teck
What the case was about Succession and Wills

Source: [2024] SGHCF 39, High Court (Family Division), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • WZJ Respondent
  • WZK Appellant
  • WZL Appellant

Counsel

Counsel for the respondent

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHCF 39)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer