Crédit Agricole Corporate & Investment Bank Singapore Branch v PPT Energy Trading Co. Ltd.

Court of Appeal (International)

[2024] SGCA(I) 3 · CA/CAS 2/2022 · CA/CAS 3/2022 · cites 8 cases

The question

Who is the successful party for costs when each side wins one of two disputes?

The answer

Typically the party found entitled to receive money, judged overall. The Court of Appeal ordered a single costs award to the bank, which won substantial damages, discounted for the letter of credit dispute it lost.

Step 1: What happened

This was the third judgment of the Court of Appeal (Judith Prakash SJ, Jonathan Hugh Mance IJ and Bernard Rix IJ) in Civil Appeals from the Singapore International Commercial Court Nos 2 and 3 of 2022, between Crédit Agricole Corporate & Investment Bank, Singapore Branch (CACIB) and PPT Energy Trading Co Ltd (PPT). The dispute arose from a fraud by Zenrock Commodities Trading Pte Ltd, which CACIB had financed. CACIB had issued a letter of credit to PPT for US$23,662,732.50 and taken a letter of indemnity from PPT. It paid the letter of credit sum on 18 November 2020 against a bank guarantee, and recovered US$6,197,532.75 of the US$16,517,443.06 sale receivables under a settlement with ING Bank.

The SICC judge found for PPT on both disputes and awarded it interest and costs. In its liability judgment of 24 October 2023, the Court of Appeal allowed CACIB's appeals in part: CACIB had to honour the letter of credit, but PPT had breached its warranty of marketable title and owed damages, later confirmed at US$10,319,910.31. The court set aside the judge's interest and costs orders. This judgment decided interest and the costs of the trial and the appeals.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether and for what periods each party was entitled to interest on the sums owed to it
  2. Whether PPT was entitled to interest while the bank guarantee remained in place and on a loan it had taken
  3. Which party was the successful party for costs, and whether costs should be decided issue by issue
  4. How the contractual indemnity for reasonable legal fees in the letter of indemnity affected the costs awarded

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On interest, CACIB owed the letter of credit sum from its due date of 5 June 2020 until it paid on 18 November 2020. But PPT became liable in damages for the receivables when TOTSA paid them to the escrow agent on 17 June 2020, so after that date PPT's interest ran only on the difference. CACIB's interest ran on the full receivables until its settlement recovery on 9 December 2020, then on the net damages. Once CACIB paid, there was no outstanding debt; PPT's dealings over the bank guarantee and its own loan had nothing to do with CACIB.

On who won, the court looked at the litigation overall in a realistic and commercially sensible way, following Comfort Management Pte Ltd v OGSP Engineering Pte Ltd and another [2022] 5 SLR 525. CACIB had obtained substantial damages against vigorous resistance and was the successful party. PPT's complete success on the letter of credit was reflected by an overall discount, not an issue-based award.

The court left open whether it keeps a discretion when a contractual costs right is enforced directly, because the indemnity covered only "reasonable legal fees", which the court must assess. Costs were therefore not confined to the standard scale but were cut where unreasonable. Mayer Brown's pre-transfer fees of close to US$1m were significantly reduced for overlap with local counsel, missing detail and the limited focus on the indemnity claim. Its post-transfer fees were halved, and English counsel's appeal fees were reduced to £200,000 because PPT should not bear CACIB's change of counsel.

Treating the two disputes as of similar complexity, the court deducted two-thirds, since CACIB should bear its own and PPT's costs of the dispute it lost. The generous discount also reflected that CACIB won on damages only after changing its case at the appeal hearing.

From the judgment

“In commercial litigation, where the dispute is ultimately about money, the event is typically in favour of the party whom the court has found is entitled to receive money”

[2024] SGCA(I) 3 at [38]

Step 4: The order

The court ordered interest at 5.33% per annum both ways. PPT received interest on US$23,662,732.50 from 5 June 2020 to 17 June 2020 (US$41,464.89) and on US$7,145,289.44 from 17 June 2020 to 18 November 2020 (US$160,684.84). CACIB received interest on US$16,517,443.06 from 18 November 2020 to 9 December 2020 (US$50,651.98) and on US$10,319,910.31 from 9 December 2020 until payment. CACIB was also entitled to a refund of US$1,983,971.30 paid under the set-aside orders, with interest from 14 April 2022 until repayment. A single costs award was made to CACIB after a two-third discount: S$269,873.18, US$256,560.90 and £129,224.17.

Terms in this case

Letter of credit
A bank's promise, made at a buyer's request, to pay a seller once the seller presents documents that strictly match the terms of the credit. The bank's duty to pay is separate from the sale contract and is refused only in narrow cases such as fraud.
Indemnity
A promise by one person to make good another's loss or liability arising from a stated event, such as a claim by a third party. The word also describes a right to be reimbursed that the law gives in some relationships, such as an agent's right against the principal.

Court record

Key facts

Court Court of Appeal (International)
Decided
Judges Bernard Rix, Jonathan Hugh Mance, Judith Prakash
What the case was about Civil Procedure

Source: [2024] SGCA(I) 3, Court of Appeal (International), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judges

Parties

  • Crédit Agricole Corporate & Investment Bank, Singapore Branch Appellant
  • PPT Energy Trading Co Ltd Respondent

Counsel

Counsel for the respondent

Cases cited (8)

SG (4)
SLR (4)
  • [1988] 1 SLR(R) 76
  • [2014] 3 SLR 909
  • [2015] 4 SLR 1019
  • [2022] 5 SLR 525

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA(I) 3)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer