Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri and others v Lakshmi Anil Salgaocar suing as the Administratrix of the Estate of Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar (India Passport No.HXXXXXXX),deceased and another

High Court (Appellate Division)

[2024] SGHC(A) 27 · AD/CA 88/2023 · cites 14 cases (10 Singapore, 4 foreign) · cited by 4 cases

The question

Can an oral agreement to hold company shares on trust be upheld despite the lack of documents?

The answer

Yes. The Appellate Division upheld findings that an oral 2003 agreement created a trust, that the trustee breached it and that no Indian law was broken, and dismissed the appeal save for one order on records.

Step 1: What happened

Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar, an Indian businessman who exported iron ore, sued Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri, a Hong Kong-based businessman, in Suit 821 of 2015 for breach of trust. He claimed that under an oral agreement in December 2003 he would fund special purpose vehicles (SPVs) to trade iron ore into China, with Mr Darsan holding shares in them on trust for him in return for US$0.50 per wet metric ton sold. Six SPVs were incorporated in the British Virgin Islands and others in Singapore; the trading profits allegedly funded the Singapore SPVs' purchases of vessels and property. He alleged that between 2011 and 2014 Mr Darsan, among other things, diverted large sums to himself or connected entities, refused to follow his instructions or return the assets, transferred property units away, and altered accounting records. Mr Darsan's case was that the business and assets were his.

Mr Salgaocar died on 1 January 2016, and his widow continued the suit as administratrix. After a trial the High Court judge found that the agreement and trust existed, that Mr Darsan breached it in several ways, and that the agreement was not illegal under Indian law. He ordered the trust assets transferred to the estate, an account on a wilful default basis, delivery up of books and records, and indemnity costs with a 33 per cent uplift. Mr Darsan and 11 Singapore SPVs appealed (AD/CA 88/2023), amid many related applications in Singapore and India.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the December 2003 Agreement existed and gave rise to the 2003 Trust.
  2. Whether the agreement breached Indian laws so that the trust claims were unenforceable for foreign illegality.
  3. Whether the trust failed for lack of certainty, and whether Mr Darsan breached it.
  4. Whether an account on a wilful default basis and indemnity costs were properly ordered.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The judge had not simply found for the estate because he disbelieved Mr Darsan; he examined evidence that Mr Salgaocar made the significant decisions about the SPVs and that Mr Darsan had no prior iron ore trading experience. Mr Salgaocar's apparent inaction was explained by his learning of the unauthorised transfers only in August 2013, after which he engaged lawyers. There was no evidence that Mr Darsan personally funded the SPVs, while Mr Salgaocar had guaranteed loans. The close, father-and-son relationship explained the lack of documents.

On Indian law, the court upheld the findings that there was no breach. A foreign exchange breach would be rectifiable, and Mr Salgaocar was not shown to be resident in India in 2003. The black money legislation post-dated the agreement, so any later non-disclosure was separate from the agreement itself, and the money laundering claim depended on it. The benami law did not apply to assets outside India, the tax disclosure duty began only in 2011, and there was no evidence of customs underdeclaration. In any event, the foreign illegality principles apply only to contract claims.

The trust was certain even though its subject matter lay partly in the future, and Mr Darsan's nominal transfers of assets after the demand letter showed the intended trust. The breaches were supported by the evidence, and acquiescence was not made out. An account on a wilful default basis was justified, but it was unclear which BVI records had already been handed over. Indemnity costs require a high degree of unreasonableness, not bad faith, and the judge's findings, including on the timing of the third-party action against a former employee, supported them.

From the judgment

“A claimant only discharges his burden of proof if the court believes his case to be proved and not simply because the court disbelieves the other side’s version of events unless clearly there is no other possible version.”

[2024] SGHC(A) 27 at [71]

Step 4: The order

The Appellate Division (Woo Bih Li JAD, Debbie Ong Siew Ling JAD and See Kee Oon JAD) dismissed the appeal, save for setting aside the order for delivery up of the books and records of the BVI SPVs and their subsidiaries. A later application by the estate to correct the court's order so that it covered only those BVI records was allowed. Mr Darsan was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the appeal fixed at $100,000.

Terms in this case

Breach of trust
A trustee's failure, by act or omission, to perform a duty owed under the trust, such as misapplying trust property or failing to act with proper care; the trustee is personally liable to make good the loss or account for any gain.
Express trust
A trust deliberately created by the owner of property, by words or conduct, which requires certainty of intention to create a trust, certainty of the property subject to it, and certainty of the beneficiaries or objects.
Burden of proof
The obligation on a party to prove a fact to the required standard, failing which that party loses on that point. In its main sense, the legal burden, it rests on whoever asserts the fact under the Evidence Act 1893 and does not shift during the trial, unlike the evidential burden.
Illegality
The doctrine under which a court may refuse to enforce a contract, or to allow a claim, where the contract or its performance involves breaking a statute or is contrary to public policy. Whether money or property already transferred can be recovered depends on further rules.
Indemnity costs
A basis for assessing the legal costs one party must pay another that is more generous than the usual standard basis: any doubt about whether a cost was reasonable is resolved in favour of the receiving party. It is often ordered for unreasonable conduct or where a contract provides for it.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court (Appellate Division)
Decided
Judges Debbie Ong Siew Ling, See Kee Oon, Woo Bih Li
What the case was about Trusts, Contract

Source: [2024] SGHC(A) 27, High Court (Appellate Division), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Statutes cited

Cases cited (14)

Cited by (4)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Statutes interpreted in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC(A) 27)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer