Iskandar bin Rahmat and others v Attorney-General of Singapore
[2024] SGHC 122 · HC/OA 306/2024 ( HC/SUM 1124/2024 ) · cites 14 cases (13 Singapore, 1 foreign) · cited by 3 cases
Do prisoners awaiting capital punishment have a constitutional right to free counsel after their appeals?
No. The High Court held Article 9(3) gives a right to counsel of one's choice who is willing and able to act, not to be given counsel, and allowed the Attorney-General's application to strike out the claim.
Step 1: What happened
The applicants, Iskandar bin Rahmat and 35 others, were each convicted of a capital offence and awaiting capital punishment. They alleged that the Legal Aid Scheme for Capital Offences (LASCO) had a policy of not assigning counsel for post-appeal applications. In Originating Application No 306 of 2024 they sought a declaration that this policy was inconsistent with Arts 9 and 12 of the Constitution, and damages. The Attorney-General applied in Summons No 1124 of 2024 to strike out the application under O 9 r 16(1)(a) of the Rules of Court 2021 for disclosing no reasonable cause of action. The Attorney-General did not contest that the policy existed.
Under the LASCO Guidelines, counsel is assigned for capital trials and may be extended to appeals, with assignment ending when the appeal is decided. The applicants relied on a court e-mail of 14 November 2017 stating the Registry's policy not to assign LASCO counsel for post-appeal applications, refusals of their later requests, and a clause in LASCO consent forms. At the hearing on 9 May 2024 the applicants, who had filed no written submissions despite directions, orally sought an adjournment of four to five weeks, saying they were jailhouse litigants. Although strictly no affidavit evidence could be considered on such an application, the Judge considered their affidavits to deal fully with their arguments.
Step 2: What the court had to decide
- Whether the applicants should be granted an adjournment to file written submissions.
- Whether the LASCO policy breached the right to counsel under Art 9(3) or an alleged right of access to justice under Art 9(1) of the Constitution.
- Whether the LASCO policy breached the right to equality under Art 12(1) of the Constitution.
Step 3: How the court reasoned
On the adjournment, the Judge held that the applicants, having brought OA 306 themselves, must have known its basis, and two weeks was enough even with the constraints of prison.
On Art 9(3), the right is to consult and be defended by counsel of one's choice who is willing and able to act. Nothing in its text gives a right to be provided with counsel, still less free counsel. The policy might reflect allocating resources to accused persons yet to be tried or preventing abuse, and the principle of finality applies even in capital cases once appeal and review have run their course. LASCO was entitled to adopt or change its policy. The capital nature of the punishment did not allow the court to read in rights the Constitution did not contain, and earlier Court of Appeal decisions had rejected the claim that costs provisions deter lawyers from acting.
The Art 9(1) and fettering arguments failed on the facts. The applicants were sentenced on the basis of their convictions after trial and appeal, not because of the policy, and a person without free representation can still engage counsel; the policy was not unreasonable.
On Art 12(1), applying the test in Syed Suhail bin Syed Zin v Attorney-General [2021] 1 SLR 809, the applicants had to show they were equally situated with those treated differently. The earlier instances they cited predated the policy, which came into existence in late 2017 or after, and the Ilechukwu matter arose from a motion filed on 5 April 2017. No post-policy case of LASCO counsel for a post-appeal application was shown. The Judge also noted the many applications by largely the same applicants and warned that meritless applications would be struck out.
“The right to counsel in Art 9(3) cannot be interpreted as a right to be provided with counsel, much less counsel that is given at no cost.”
[2024] SGHC 122 at [20]
Step 4: The order
The High Court refused the adjournment and allowed the Attorney-General's striking-out application, striking out OA 306 in its entirety, including the damages claim, as disclosing no reasonable cause of action. As the Attorney-General sought no costs, no order as to costs was made.
Terms in this case
- Striking out
- A court order removing all or part of a pleading or other document, for example because it discloses no reasonable cause of action, is frivolous or vexatious, or is an abuse of process. It can end a claim or defence without a full trial.
- Cause of action
- The set of facts that gives a person a legal right to sue another person and ask the court for a remedy, such as a breach of contract or an act of negligence.
Court record
Key facts
| Court | High Court |
|---|---|
| Decided | |
| Judge | Dedar Singh Gill |
| What the case was about | Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law |
Source: [2024] SGHC 122, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .
Judge
- Dedar Singh Gill Delivered the judgment
Parties
- Attorney-General Respondent
- A Steven Raj s/o Paul Raj Applicant
- Chandroo Subramaniam Applicant
- Chong Hoon Cheong Applicant
- Eddie Lee Zheng Da Applicant
- Gunalan Goval Applicant
- Iskandar bin Rahmat Applicant
- Jumaat bin Mohamed Sayed Applicant
- Jumadi bin Abdullah Applicant
- Kishor Kumar A/L Raguan Applicant
- Lingkesvaran Rajendaren Applicant
- Masoud Rahimi bin Mehrzad Applicant
- Moad Fadzir bin Mustaffa Applicant
- Mohamed Ansari bin Mohamed Abdul Aziz Applicant
- Mohammad Azwan bin Bohari Applicant
- Mohammad Reduan bin Mustaffar Applicant
- Mohammad Rizwan bin Akbar Husain Applicant
- Mohd Akebal s/o Ghulam Jilani Applicant
- Muhammad Hamir bin Laka Applicant
- Muhammad Salleh bin Hamid Applicant
- Omar bin Yacob Bamadhaj Applicant
- Pannir Selvam a/l Pranthaman Applicant
- Pausi bin Jefridin Applicant
- Ramdhan bin Lajis Applicant
- Roshdi bin Abdullah Altway Applicant
- Roslan bin Bakar Applicant
- Rosman bin Abdullah Applicant
- Saminathan Selvaraju Applicant
- Sanjay Krishnan Applicant
- Shen Hanjie Applicant
- Shisham bin Abdul Rahman Applicant
- Steve Crocker Applicant
- Sulaiman bin Jumari Applicant
- Syed Suhail bin Syed Zin Applicant
- Tan Kay Yong Applicant
- Teo Ghim Heng Applicant
- Zamri bin Mohd Tahir Applicant
Counsel
Statutes cited
Cases cited (14)
- Masoud Rahimi bin Mehrzad and others v Attorney-General of Singapore [2023] SGHC 346
- The Law Society of Singapore v Cheng Kim Kuan [2023] SGHC 350
- Masoud Rahimi bin Mehrzad and others v Attorney-General of Singapore [2024] SGCA 11
- [2022] SGCA 46
- [1996] 1 SLR(R) 853
- [1997] 3 SLR(R) 649
- [2016] 3 SLR 135
- [2021] 1 SLR 67
- [2021] 1 SLR 809
- [2022] 2 SLR 1018
- [2022] 2 SLR 668
- [2023] 4 SLR 1133
- [2023] 4 SLR 1760
- [1980] 2 MLJ 201
Cited by (3)
- Roslan bin Bakar v Attorney-General of Singapore [2024] SGCA 51
- Sulaiman bin Jumari v Public Prosecutor [2024] SGCA 40
- Mohammad Azwan bin Bohari v Public Prosecutor [2024] SGCA 38
Related cases
Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.
-
Can death-row prisoners challenge the post-appeal application rules before any of them has applied under them?
High Court · 5 February 2025 · [2025] SGHC 20 -
Can prisoners challenge a law on post-appeal capital case applications before it comes into force?
High Court · 5 December 2023 · [2023] SGHC 346 -
Can death penalty campaigners, including sisters of executed prisoners, challenge the mandatory death penalty without facing prosecution?
Court of Appeal · 3 September 2026 · [2026] SGCA 39 -
Are the drug law presumptions of possession and knowledge unconstitutional?
Court of Appeal · 28 August 2025 · [2025] SGCA 40 -
Can prisoners challenge a law's constitutionality before that law comes into force?
Court of Appeal · 27 March 2024 · [2024] SGCA 11 -
Must a judge step aside from a case because he ruled against the same party before?
High Court · 6 February 2024 · [2024] SGHC 35
Referenced in
Statutes interpreted in this judgment
Read the full judgment
The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.
Read on eLitigationSource: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 122)
This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer