Tjiang Giok Moy and another v Ang Jimmy Tjun Min

High Court

[2024] SGHC 146 · HC/OC 56/2022 ( HC/SUM 1189/2024,HC/SUM 308/2024 ) · cites 6 cases (5 Singapore, 1 foreign)

The question

Can parties who oppose a production order sought against a non-party bank recover their costs?

The answer

Yes. The High Court held the claimants had standing to be heard and, as the successful party, were entitled to costs, but refused indemnity costs, allowing their request in part with $10,000 on the standard basis.

Step 1: What happened

This was a costs decision in Originating Claim No 56 of 2022 in the General Division of the High Court, brought by the claimants Tjiang Giok Moy and Ang Eileen against the defendant Ang Jimmy Tjun Min. The defendant had applied in Summons No 308 of 2024 for an order requiring a non-party, Citibank NA, to produce documents, and in Summons No 1189 of 2024 for leave to amend that application.

Citibank NA objected to the production order. The claimants, although the order was not sought against them, also made submissions opposing it. Kwek Mean Luck J dismissed both summonses on 23 May 2024. The remaining question was whether the claimants, as parties to the main claim who were not the target of the production order, could recover their costs of the two summonses, and on what basis.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the claimants had standing to be heard on a production application aimed at a non-party bank
  2. Whether the claimants were entitled to costs as a successful party to the two summonses
  3. Whether costs should be ordered on the indemnity basis rather than the standard basis

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On standing, the court relied on Xing Rong Pte Ltd (formerly known as Huadi Projects Pte Ltd) v Visionhealthone Corp Pte Ltd [2010] 4 SLR 607, where the Court of Appeal held that a discovery order against a non-party could affect the interests of the parties to the main suit, who were therefore entitled to be heard. The defendant conceded the point. Although the Rules of Court 2021 no longer require such applications to be served on every party, the judge considered that the principle remained relevant, since the rule of natural justice that parties be given a chance to be heard applies where their property and interests are at stake.

On entitlement, O 21 r 3(2) of the Rules of Court 2021 requires the court generally to order costs in favour of a successful party. Because the claimants had a right to appear and oppose, they had to be treated as parties to the summonses for costs purposes. The defendant's argument that the claimants had protracted matters was rejected: their submissions were an exercise of their right to be heard. The defendant's reliance on the costs order in Xing Rong did not help, because there the parties bore their own costs only because the appeal would have failed on the merits anyway.

On the basis of costs, indemnity costs are the exception, and the court applied the categories of conduct identified in Airtrust (Hong Kong) Ltd v PH Hydraulics & Engineering Pte Ltd [2016] 5 SLR 103. Although Summons No 1189 of 2024 was dismissed because the defendant had not shown the materiality of the documents or that they existed or were bankers' books, that conduct did not reach the high threshold. On quantum, the judge awarded costs toward the higher end of the Practice Directions range because of the defendant's eleventh-hour amendment, which caused an adjournment and wasted costs, and the volume of material the claimants had filed.

From the judgment

“the Claimants, as a successful party in SUM 308 and SUM 1189, would be entitled to costs in their favour.”

[2024] SGHC 146 at [12]

“I did not consider the Defendant’s conduct in SUM 1189 to cross the high threshold warranting costs on an indemnity basis.”

[2024] SGHC 146 at [16]

Step 4: The order

The court allowed the claimants' request for costs in part. It held that they had standing and were entitled to costs as the successful party, but refused the indemnity costs they sought. It awarded costs on the standard basis in the total amount of $10,000 all in, made up of $4000 for wasted costs in Summons No 308 of 2024, $4500 for Summons No 1189 of 2024, and $1500 for the costs submissions.

Terms in this case

Natural justice
The basic rules of fair procedure that a court, tribunal or other decision-maker must follow: each side must have a fair chance to be heard, and the decision-maker must not be biased or appear to be biased.
Production of documents
Making relevant documents available to the other party or the court for inspection. Under the current Rules of Court, it is the name for the process formerly called discovery, under which parties must produce documents they rely on and those that harm their own case.
Indemnity costs
A basis for assessing the legal costs one party must pay another that is more generous than the usual standard basis: any doubt about whether a cost was reasonable is resolved in favour of the receiving party. It is often ordered for unreasonable conduct or where a contract provides for it.
Standard basis
The usual basis on which a court assesses the legal costs one party must pay another: a reasonable amount for costs reasonably incurred, with any doubt about whether a cost was reasonable resolved in favour of the paying party.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Kwek Mean Luck
What the case was about Civil Procedure

Source: [2024] SGHC 146, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

Counsel

Cases cited (6)

SG (2)
  • [2013] SGHC 274
  • [2022] SGHC 188
SLR (3)
  • [2010] 1 SLR 733
  • [2010] 4 SLR 607
  • [2016] 5 SLR 103
UK (1)
  • [2006] EWHC 816

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 146)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer