Nagarajan Murugesan v Grand Rich Electrical & Engineering Pte. Ltd. and others

High Court

[2024] SGHC 36 · HC/DCA 4/2023 · cites 21 cases (17 Singapore, 4 foreign) · cited by 1 case

The question

How much blame does a banksman bear for standing in an excavator's blind spot?

The answer

Only 10% here. The High Court allowed his appeal, cut his contributory negligence from 33.33% to 10%, and gave judgment against his employer, the neighbouring site's operator and the main contractor jointly and severally for 90% of damages.

Step 1: What happened

Mr Nagarajan Murugesan, a construction labourer employed by Grand Rich Electrical & Engineering Pte Ltd, was working as a banksman at a roadworks site at Yishun Avenue 7 on 16 May 2019. Yuan Ji Enterprises Pte Ltd was the main contractor and occupier and had subcontracted the excavation to his employer. Across a single traffic lane was a site run by Eng Lee Engineering Pte Ltd. When one of Eng Lee's trucks could not get into its site, Mr Nagarajan went to the front right of the stationary excavator to pull the water barriers inwards. Eng Lee's banksman told the excavator operator to move forward. The operator later did so, without instructions from Mr Nagarajan, and hit him, causing serious foot and ankle fractures.

He sued all three companies in DC/S 1040/2019. The District Judge held his employer and Eng Lee liable, found the main contractor not liable, and assessed his contributory negligence at 33.33%, granting interlocutory judgment for 66.67% of damages. He appealed to the High Court in District Court Appeal No 4 of 2023.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the employer breached its duty by failing to implement a horning system and blind-spot cameras on the excavator
  2. Whether the main contractor breached its duty of care or was vicariously liable for the operator's negligence
  3. Whether the District Judge's finding of 33.33% contributory negligence should be reduced
  4. Whether the court could apportion liability among the defendants without any contribution claim

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The court found the employer's safety measures inadequate. Its banksman system and procedures provided no further check if an operator moved without authorisation, and the excavator's beeping, which sounded less than two seconds before it moved and blended into traffic noise, was not a true safety measure. A horning system before moving forward was cheap and simple, already required before reversing, and not a matter of hindsight, so failing to adopt it was a breach. The claim about cameras failed for want of evidence on cost and feasibility.

The main contractor was found to have briefed the appellant on blind spots and was entitled under the subcontract to rely on the employer's supervisor. But it had admitted responsibility for coordinating with the neighbouring site, foresaw the vehicle access problem, set up no point of contact, and did not show its traffic controllers were present. That failure to coordinate was a breach that likely would have prevented the accident. It was not vicariously liable, because the operator worked for an independent contractor.

On contributory negligence, the appellant was at fault for standing in a blind spot against safety protocol. But the operator's evidence that he had switched off the engine was preferred, the appellant reasonably expected the excavator to stay put without his signal, he was working under pressure in a chaotic setting the respondents had helped create, and the operator moved only minutes after the other banksman's instruction. The District Judge had been plainly wrong, and the cases relied on were distinguishable, so the appellant's share was fixed at 10%. As no contribution claims had been filed between the respondents, the District Judge ought not to have apportioned liability among them.

From the judgment

“In the static environment of the court room, it is simple to conjure up counterfactuals of what a party could have and should have done. However, the court must be attuned to the realities of a dynamic worksite.”

[2024] SGHC 36 at [69]

Step 4: The order

Dedar Singh Gill J allowed the appeal and ordered judgment for the appellant against the three respondents jointly and severally for 90% of damages to be assessed, with costs to be heard separately.

The order in the court's words

Appeal allowed

“I allow the appeal.”

Source: [2024] SGHC 36, High Court, decided 8 February 2024. Read directly from the judgment.

Terms in this case

Contributory negligence
A claimant's own failure to take reasonable care for their safety, which helped cause the harm. Damages are then reduced in proportion to the claimant's share of the blame. In sentencing for driving offences, a victim's own carelessness that affected the degree of the offender's negligence may reduce the offender's culpability.
Negligence
A tort in which a person who owes another a duty of care breaches it by falling below the required standard of care, causing damage that is not too remote; in criminal law, a failure to take reasonable care that forms part of some offences.
Duty of care
A legal obligation to take reasonable care not to cause another person harm; in Singapore it arises where harm was factually foreseeable, the parties were in a relationship of sufficient legal proximity, and no policy reason weighs against imposing it.
Vicarious liability
The rule that makes one person, usually an employer, answerable for a wrong committed by another, usually an employee acting in the course of employment, even though the first person did nothing wrong.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Dedar Singh Gill
What the case was about Tort
Outcome Appeal allowed

Source: [2024] SGHC 36, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • Eng Lee Engineering Pte Ltd Respondent
  • Grand Rich Electrical & Engineering Pte Ltd Respondent
  • Yuan Ji Enterprises Pte Ltd Respondent
  • Nagarajan Murugesan Appellant

Counsel

Counsel for the appellant
Counsel for the respondent

Statutes cited

Contributory Negligence and Personal Injuries Act
s 3(1)

Cases cited (21)

SG (5)
SLR (12)
  • [1999] 3 SLR(R) 377
  • [2002] 2 SLR(R) 321
  • [2007] 4 SLR(R) 100
  • [2007] 4 SLR(R) 513
  • [2012] 3 SLR 1038
  • [2014] 2 SLR 7
  • [2015] 3 SLR 201
  • [2016] 2 SLR 944
  • [2017] 2 SLR 1074
  • [2021] 2 SLR 1267
  • [2021] 4 SLR 1371
  • [2022] 2 SLR 743
UK (4)
  • [1943] AC 197
  • [1967] 1 AC 617
  • [2012] 3 WLR 1319
  • [2015] UKSC 5

Cited by (1)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Statutes interpreted in this judgment

Liability apportioned in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 36)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer