Lim Ing Haan (Lin Yinghong) v Tuan 'Abdu Qayyim bin Tuan Isa

High Court

[2024] SGHC 86 · HC/S 383/2020 · cites 4 cases

The question

Can an injured doctor recover loss of future earnings even though her income rose after the accident?

The answer

Yes, in part. The High Court held that rising income did not disprove a future loss, found likely wrist surgery would cut her working capacity by 25%, and assessed the loss at $2,494,366.85.

Step 1: What happened

Ms Lim Ing Haan is an interventional cardiologist and a director of her own cardiology clinic. Her work involves complex procedures that depend on her right wrist. On 4 May 2017 Mr Tuan 'Abdu Qayyim bin Tuan Isa, turning right from the second lane of Bukit Timah Road, collided with her car. She suffered serious right wrist injuries, including a comminuted distal radius fracture and several ligament tears, and had surgery the same day.

She sued in Suit No 383 of 2020, and on 11 May 2021 interlocutory judgment was entered by consent against Mr Tuan at 100%, with damages to be assessed in the General Division of the High Court. The parties agreed pain and suffering at $40,000, future medical expenses at $70,000 and past medical expenses at $40,740.20. The medical experts agreed that she would need further wrist surgery within the next 5 years and that she would not return to her pre-accident state, setting out best, moderate and worst-case outcomes.

The central dispute was her loss of future earnings. She finally claimed $12,294,165, or alternatively provisional damages. Mr Tuan said she was entitled to nothing because her practice's revenue had risen since the accident, or at most $194,550 or $292,413 on his accounting expert's figures.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether, when and what kind of future surgery the plaintiff was likely to undergo, and how long she would be off work.
  2. Whether the expected surgery would reduce her working capacity, given that her income had risen since the accident.
  3. How her loss of future earnings should be calculated, including the reduction in surgical and other revenue and whether an age discount applied.
  4. Whether provisional damages should be awarded instead.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the surgery, Ms Lim intended to delay it as long as her pain allowed. Accepting Mr Tuan's position, which fell within the experts' agreed range, the court found she would likely have it by end 2027. As all experts agreed treatment would revolve around partial fusion and she had no firm preference, it took a partial wrist fusion as the likely procedure, and it allowed seven months off work, adding a month to the experts' minimum of six.

On working capacity, the court rejected the argument that rising post-accident income disproved any future reduction. Her income could be explained by workload, case complexity, rising fees, seniority and patient numbers, and by her own determination. The experts unanimously agreed that a partial fusion would reduce her working capacity by 20% to 30%, and the court took 25%.

On quantification, the court rejected the plaintiff's expert's assumption of repeated 50% reductions every five years, because the medical report it came from described her capacity before any surgery. It rejected the defendant's expert's 15% age discount as unexplained and as duplicating the vicissitudes already built into the agreed multiplier. It found surgical revenue would fall by 25% and, preferring the plaintiff's expert's approach that other revenue would fall by half as much, other revenue by 12.5%. The defendant's assumption of 4% annual growth in non-surgical revenue was speculative because that revenue flowed from her surgical work. The figures were then applied from 2028 to her retirement at 70, after tax and the agreed multipliers.

The $12,294,165 figure rested on her undergoing total fusion and losing all surgical revenue, which the evidence did not support. Since her loss of future earnings was established and assessed, provisional damages did not need to be decided.

From the judgment

“She has not lost her livelihood as an interventional cardiologist.”

[2024] SGHC 86 at [105]

“Past events are not necessarily a reliable indicator or predictor of future outcomes.”

[2024] SGHC 86 at [46]

Step 4: The order

The court allowed the claim for loss of future earnings in part, assessing it at $2,494,366.85 rather than the $12,294,165 sought. It awarded the agreed $40,000 for pain and suffering with interest at 5.33% from the writ, $70,000 for future medical expenses without interest, $40,740.20 for medical expenses with interest at 2.67% from the accident, and no interest on the future earnings award. It found it unnecessary to decide on provisional damages and reserved costs for further submissions.

Terms in this case

Loss of future earnings
A head of damages in a personal injury or fatal accident claim for the income the claimant would have earned after trial if not for the injury, often worked out by multiplying an annual loss by a number of years.
Interlocutory judgment
A judgment, including one entered by consent or in default, that decides liability or declares rights but leaves damages, an account or another matter to be decided later.
Pain and suffering
A head of general damages in a personal injury claim for the physical pain and mental distress caused by the injury, usually assessed together with loss of amenity.
Assessment of damages
The stage of a civil case at which the court works out how much money is to be paid as damages, often held separately after liability has already been decided and frequently heard by a registrar.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge See Kee Oon
What the case was about Damages

Source: [2024] SGHC 86, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • Lim Ing Haan Plaintiff
  • Tuan ‘Abdu Qayyim bin Tuan Isa Defendant

Counsel

Counsel for the plaintiff
  • Joseph Lopez LLP Firm
  • Joseph Lopez
  • Mubin Shah
  • Pearline Chia
Counsel for the defendant

Cases cited (4)

SG (1)
  • [2022] SGHC 102
SLR (3)
  • [1994] 1 SLR(R) 340
  • [2018] 3 SLR 244
  • [2022] 4 SLR 1045

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Legal concepts and references

Damages awarded in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 86)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer