Moad Fadzir Bin Mustaffa v Public Prosecutor
[2024] SGCA 20 · CA/CM 15/2024 · cites 9 cases · cited by 1 case
Can a prisoner make a second application for permission to seek a review of his conviction?
No. The Court of Appeal held s 394K(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code allows only one review application and so only one permission application, and summarily dismissed the motion.
Step 1: What happened
Moad Fadzir bin Mustaffa was convicted in the High Court of trafficking in not less than 36.93 grams of diamorphine, found in a sling bag he was carrying when he was arrested on 12 April 2016 outside his home at Woodlands Drive 52. Earlier that night he had driven a car, with Zuraimy bin Musa as passenger, to Toa Payoh, where an unknown Indian man threw a white plastic bag through the window. Each man said the drugs belonged to the other. Mr Moad Fadzir received the mandatory death penalty; Zuraimy was convicted of abetment on an amended charge. In 2019 the Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction and sentence, finding that Mr Moad Fadzir transacted in the drugs and Zuraimy acted as middleman.
A first application for permission to seek a review, CM 29, was summarily dismissed in 2020. After an execution date was set for 26 April 2024, Mr Moad Fadzir filed this second permission application, Criminal Motion No 15 of 2024, under s 394H of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010. Its basis was a handwritten statement by Kishor, a fellow death-row prisoner, who claimed to be the man who threw the bag and said a person called Boy Kejr had asked him to pass the drugs to Zuraimy and collect money from him. The applicant also alleged that the Prosecution knew of Kishor and breached its disclosure duties. A separate application asking the judge to recuse himself had already been dismissed.
Step 2: What the court had to decide
- Whether a second application for permission to make a review application was barred by s 394K(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code.
- Whether the court's inherent power of review should be invoked.
- Whether Kishor's statement was sufficient material showing a miscarriage of justice under s 394J.
- Whether the Prosecution breached its disclosure obligations by not disclosing Kishor's statement.
Step 3: How the court reasoned
The judge held that because s 394K(1) allows only one review application, an applicant also cannot make more than one application for permission, which is the necessary first step. This alone disposed of the motion. The inherent power of review preserved by s 394J(1)(b) is a last resort for the most exceptional cases, where new material makes the facts practically irrefutable and shows a miscarriage of justice conclusively. A different factual narrative does not meet that bar.
Even assuming Kishor was telling the truth, his account did not undermine the earlier findings. He did not know the source of the money, whether Zuraimy acted for himself or as a middleman, or what Zuraimy meant to do with the drugs. That Boy Kejr told him to deal with Zuraimy did not show Zuraimy was the principal, especially as both men were in the car. The drugs were in the applicant's possession, other drugs and paraphernalia were found in his flat, and nothing incriminating was found at Zuraimy's addresses. Kishor's evidence did not touch these points.
The judge also found Kishor not credible. By his own account he denied to the CNB that he delivered drugs at Block 157 because the meeting had in fact been at the neighbouring Block 156A, which the judge saw as an attempt to mislead.
On disclosure, given Kishor's denial of involvement, the Prosecution had insufficient evidence to treat him as a material witness. The applicant himself had not recognised Kishor from a photograph shown to him on 31 August 2016, and nor had Zuraimy. The disclosure duties were therefore not engaged or breached, and with or without Kishor the finding that the applicant transacted in the drugs stood.
“The court’s inherent power will therefore never be invoked simply because an applicant puts forward a different factual narrative or claims that certain allegations should be examined further.”
[2024] SGCA 20 at [28]
“With or without Kishor’s evidence, that narrative remains unchanged. There was therefore no miscarriage of justice whatsoever.”
[2024] SGCA 20 at [36]
Step 4: The order
Tay Yong Kwang JCA, sitting alone, summarily dismissed the application. A second application for permission was prohibited by s 394K(1), and in any event the application disclosed no legitimate basis under s 394J for the Court of Appeal's power of review.
Terms in this case
- Review application
- An application under the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 asking an appellate court to reopen its own earlier decision in a criminal matter. It needs the court's permission, generally only one is allowed per decision, and the applicant must show new and compelling material indicating a miscarriage of justice.
- Miscarriage of justice
- A serious failure in the outcome of a case, such as a conviction or sentence that is demonstrably wrong or a decision tainted by fraud or a breach of natural justice, which an appeal or review court may correct.
Court record
Key facts
| Court | Court of Appeal |
|---|---|
| Decided | |
| Judge | Tay Yong Kwang |
| What the case was about | Criminal Procedure and Sentencing |
Source: [2024] SGCA 20, Court of Appeal, decided — eLitigation. Updated .
Judge
- Tay Yong Kwang Delivered the judgment
Parties
- Public Prosecutor Respondent
- Moad Fadzir bin Mustaffa Applicant
Counsel
Statutes cited
Cases cited (9)
- Chander Kumar a/l Jayagaran v Public Prosecutor [2023] SGCA 35
- Moad Fadzir Bin Mustaffa v Public Prosecutor [2024] SGCA 18
- [2019] SGCA 73
- [2020] SGCA 97
- [2016] 3 SLR 135
- [2020] 1 SLR 984
- [2020] 2 SLR 1175
- [2021] 1 SLR 159
- [2021] 5 SLR 927
Cited by (1)
- Moad Fadzir Bin Mustaffa v Public Prosecutor [2024] SGCA 24
Related cases
Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.
-
Is re-characterising trial evidence enough for permission to review a capital drug conviction?
Court of Appeal · 14 October 2026 · [2026] SGCA 41 -
Can a prisoner raise chain-of-custody doubts for the first time to reopen a capital drug appeal?
Court of Appeal · 20 August 2026 · [2026] SGCA 37 -
Can a convicted person file a second application for permission to review the dismissal of his criminal appeal?
Court of Appeal · 10 March 2026 · [2026] SGCA 11 -
Can a drug convict reopen his appeal using evidence about seized cash that could have been raised at trial?
Court of Appeal · 28 March 2025 · [2025] SGCA 15 -
Is a prisoner's own impression that cooperating would spare him death an inducement tainting his statements?
Court of Appeal · 14 February 2025 · [2025] SGCA 6 -
What is the maximum guilty-plea reduction for drug trafficking under the sentencing guidelines?
Court of Appeal · 28 November 2024 · [2024] SGCA 55
Referenced in
Statutes interpreted in this judgment
Read the full judgment
The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.
Read on eLitigationSource: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA 20)
This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer