Lo Kok Jong v Eng Beng

Court of Appeal

[2024] SGCA 28 · CA/CA 4/2024 · cites 25 cases (10 Singapore, 15 foreign) · cited by 1 case

The question

Are untargeted government medical subsidies deducted from the damages a road accident victim recovers?

The answer

Yes. The Court of Appeal held the subsidies and grants of $39,515.08 were not intended to be enjoyed over and above the damages, so they were deductible; it allowed the driver's appeal and refused a repayment order.

Step 1: What happened

On 9 January 2020 Eng Beng was crossing a road when she was hit by a vehicle driven by Lo Kok Jong, suffering injuries including a closed trimalleolar fracture of her right ankle. She sued in negligence in District Court Suit No 1467 of 2020, and interlocutory judgment was entered by consent at 85% against him.

At the assessment, the Deputy Registrar awarded $36,348.64 but refused a further $39,515.08 claimed for medical expenses that had been covered by government subsidies and grants: generic government subsidies of $19,211.57, Pioneer Generation subsidies of $148.88 and Community Hospital and drug grants of $20,155.16. The District Judge agreed. On further appeal, a High Court judge held that the payments fell within the benevolence exception to the rule against double recovery, but, as Eng Beng was willing to return them, ordered her to pay the disputed sum to the Ministry of Health for it to decide what to do with it. Lo Kok Jong appealed, and the appeal was transferred to the Court of Appeal as Civil Appeal No 4 of 2024 because it raised a novel point of law.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether government medical subsidies and grants paid towards a road accident victim's treatment are exempt from the rule against double recovery
  2. What test decides whether a collateral benefit falls within an exception to that rule
  3. Whether the court should order the victim to repay the subsidies and grants to the Ministry of Health

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Damages in tort are compensatory, so benefits a plaintiff would not have received but for the injury are prima facie deducted. The insurance and benevolence exceptions are well established, but the court found reasoning based on causation, on benefits being collateral or remote, or on an intuitive sense that the wrongdoer should not benefit, unhelpful. Adopting the purpose-based approach in National Insurance Co of New Zealand Ltd v Espagne [1961] Qd R 277, it framed the test as whether the intended purpose of the payment, objectively judged, was to give the plaintiff a sum to enjoy over and above the damages. Absent such intention, the default rule applies. The indicia are whether the plaintiff contributed to the payment, whether it indemnifies the very loss claimed, its source, and how far it is directed at the individual or at tort victims rather than the public at large. They are weighed holistically, and the court cautioned against heavy reliance on public policy.

Applied here, there was no clear legislative intent. Eng Beng had not contributed; the payments targeted exactly the medical expenses she claimed; and they came from the government and were available to citizens and permanent residents generally (or all Pioneers), without close assessment of her circumstances. The judge's view that tailoring by citizenship, means and eligibility showed an intention not to deduct was rejected. The common law in the UK had also treated such benefits as deductible. To the extent Noor Azlin bte Abdul Rahman and another v Changi General Hospital Pte Ltd and others [2021] SGHC 10 treated general, untargeted subsidies as non-deductible, it should not be followed.

At the appeal hearing, counsel for Eng Beng made repayment her only prayer and accepted that this conceded she could not keep the sums on top of damages. The court held there was no legal basis for a repayment order. Unlike Minichit Bunhom v Jazali bin Kastari and another [2018] 1 SLR 1037, there was no contractual or statutory repayment mechanism, and setting up recoupment of government benefits is a matter for the legislature and executive, as the UK experience showed. The proposed donation to a fund was an ad hoc solution, and there was no evidence of the true source of the payments.

From the judgment

“Ultimately, in our view, it was both unprincipled and impractical for the court to institute a recoupment mechanism on its own accord.”

[2024] SGCA 28 at [100]

Step 4: The order

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on 27 June 2024. The subsidies and grants of $39,515.08 were deductible from the damages payable, and the court rejected the proposal that they be repaid to the Ministry of Health, setting aside the approach taken below.

The order in the court's words

Appeal allowed

“…we allowed the appeal.”

Source: [2024] SGCA 28, Court of Appeal, decided 8 August 2024. Read directly from the judgment.

Terms in this case

Special damages
Damages for specific losses that can be calculated in money and have already been incurred by the time of trial, such as medical bills or earnings lost before trial. They must be specifically pleaded and proved.

Court record

Key facts

Court Court of Appeal
Decided
Judges Steven Chong, Sundaresh Menon, Tay Yong Kwang
What the case was about Damages
Outcome Appeal allowed

Source: [2024] SGCA 28, Court of Appeal, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judges

Parties

  • Eng Beng Respondent
  • Lo Kok Jong Appellant

Counsel

Counsel for the appellant
Counsel for the respondent

Statutes cited

Pioneer Act
s 16(1)(f)

Cases cited (25)

SG (4)
SLR (6)
  • [2000] 3 SLR(R) 31
  • [2013] 4 SLR 1317
  • [2017] 1 SLR 918
  • [2018] 1 SLR 1037
  • [2018] 2 SLR 655
  • [2022] 1 SLR 689
UK (10)
  • [1952] 1 KB 26
  • [1964] AC 326
  • [1970] AC 1
  • [1972] 1 QB 65
  • [1985] AC 20
  • [1986] 1 All ER 332
  • [1987] 1 WLR 336
  • [1988] AC 514
  • [1989] AC 807
  • [2004] 1 WLR 2683
AU (4)
  • [1961] HCA 48
  • [1983] HCA 16
  • [1994] HCA 50
  • [2009] HCA 52
MY (1)
  • [1980] 2 MLJ 39

Cited by (1)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA 28)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer