Owner and/or Demise Charterer of the vessel A SYMPHONY (IMO No. 9249324) v Owner of the vessel "SEA JUSTICE" (IMO No. 9309514)

Court of Appeal

[2024] SGCA 32 · CA/CA 11/2024 · cites 7 cases (5 Singapore, 2 foreign)

The question

Can a claimant keep Singapore ship-arrest security after its action is stayed in favour of a foreign court?

The answer

No. The Court of Appeal held that losing access to Singapore's higher limitation regime was not a legitimate juridical advantage, so the stay was not made conditional; it dismissed the appeal and the security was to be returned.

Step 1: What happened

The appellant owned and/or demise chartered the vessel A Symphony; the respondent owned the vessel Sea Justice. On 27 April 2021 the two ships collided off Qingdao, China, in Chinese territorial waters. The A Symphony was badly damaged and oil spilled into the sea. Proceedings followed in the Qingdao Maritime Court: the appellant set up a fund under the oil pollution liability convention, both sides brought collision claims, and the respondent constituted a limitation fund under the tonnage limitation regime in PRC law (the SJ Limitation Fund), against which the appellant registered a claim.

On 20 October 2022 the appellant arrested the Sea Justice in Singapore under its in rem claim in HC/ADM 61/2021 for collision damage and losses. The ship was released on 18 November 2022 after the respondent, under protest, paid S$8,846,383 into court and procured a letter of undertaking from The Swedish Club for up to US$13.5m. It was not disputed that this security was pegged to the maximum limit under Singapore's limitation regime, which is much higher than the PRC limits.

The respondent applied to stay ADM 61 on the ground of forum non conveniens. An assistant registrar stayed the action in favour of the Qingdao proceedings and ordered the security returned. The appellant did not challenge the stay itself but appealed in HC/RA 246/2023 against the return of the security, seeking a conditional stay. A judicial commissioner dismissed that appeal, and the appellant brought Civil Appeal No 11 of 2024.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the forum non conveniens stay should have been made conditional on the appellant retaining the security furnished in Singapore.
  2. Whether losing that security amounted to the loss of a legitimate juridical advantage under the second stage of the Spiliada test.
  3. Whether the principle in The Rena K gave a basis for retaining the security, and whether the appellant could later lift the stay if a Chinese judgment went unsatisfied.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The court treated the request for a conditional stay as, in substance, a challenge to the second stage of the Spiliada test. The single question was whether returning the security would deprive the appellant of a legitimate juridical advantage so important that the deprivation would be unjust. If it would, there would be good reason to attach the condition.

The court held that it would not. A limitation fund already existed in the PRC for the same claims and the appellant had lodged a claim against it. The appellant had not challenged the PRC limitation regime or the constitution of that fund. Keeping the Singapore security would undercut the rule that the choice of forum for limitation belongs to the shipowner alone, citing Evergreen International SA v Volkswagen Group Singapore Pte Ltd and others [2004] 2 SLR(R) 457. Because the security was pegged to the higher Singapore limits, the appellant was really complaining about losing access to a more generous limitation regime, and a difference between limitation regimes is not a legitimate juridical advantage: The Reecon Wolf [2012] 2 SLR 289. Retaining the security would in effect force the respondent to constitute a second limitation fund in Singapore.

The court added that The Rena K did not help the appellant. That case concerned a mandatory stay in favour of arbitration under English statute, a context outside forum non conveniens, and in Singapore the point is now covered by s 7(1) of the International Arbitration Act 1994. The appellant's plan to return and lift the stay if a Chinese judgment was not fully paid also assumed too much. A forum non conveniens stay is lifted only in exceptional circumstances striking at the basis on which it was granted, as stated in Rotary Engineering Ltd and others v Kioumji & Eslim Law Firm and another and another appeal [2017] 1 SLR 907. The stay here rested on many factors pointing to Qingdao, not on whether the fund could pay. The court also noted the appellant appeared to take conflicting positions on how far it would be bound by the Chinese court's findings.

From the judgment

“The appellant’s attempt to retain the SG Security is, in our view, a thinly veiled attempt to circumvent the shipowner’s choice of the PRC as the forum to limit its liability.”

[2024] SGCA 32 at [14]

“It is trite law that the existence of different limitation regimes does not constitute a legitimate juridical advantage under the second stage of the Spiliada test.”

[2024] SGCA 32 at [15]

Step 4: The order

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal with costs fixed at $25,000 (all-in), with the usual consequential orders. The stay of ADM 61 stood and the security was to be returned to the respondent.

The order in the court's words

Appeal dismissed

“…the appeal is dismissed with costs fixed at $25,000 (all-in), The usual consequential orders will apply.”

Source: [2024] SGCA 32, Court of Appeal, decided 26 August 2024. Read directly from the judgment.

Terms in this case

Forum non conveniens
Latin for "an inconvenient forum": the principle that a court may stay proceedings before it, or refuse permission to serve a claim abroad, where a court in another country is clearly more appropriate to decide the dispute.

Court record

Key facts

Court Court of Appeal
Decided
Judges Belinda Ang Saw Ean, Tay Yong Kwang
What the case was about Conflict of Laws, Admiralty and Shipping
Outcome Appeal dismissed

Source: [2024] SGCA 32, Court of Appeal, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judges

Parties

  • Owner and/or Demise Charterer of the vessel "A SYMPHONY" Appellant
  • Owner of the vessel "SEA JUSTICE" Respondent

Counsel

Counsel for the appellant
Counsel for the respondent

Statutes cited

Cases cited (7)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Statutes interpreted in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA 32)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer