Esr Group Limited and others v HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Singapore) Limited and another

High Court (Appellate Division)

[2024] SGHC(A) 25 · AD/CA 37/2024 ( AD/SUM 31/2024 ) · cites 5 cases (3 Singapore, 2 foreign)

The question

Can a trust deed bar unitholders with a material interest from voting on a matter at a meeting?

The answer

Yes. The Appellate Division held the trust deed's conflict clause barred the external manager's owners from voting on amendments to replace that manager, as removal put its fees at risk, and dismissed their appeal.

Step 1: What happened

Sabana Industrial Real Estate Investment Trust (Sabana REIT) was managed by an external manager indirectly wholly owned by the appellants, ESR Group Ltd and two related companies (the ESR Entities), which together held about 21% of the units. The external manager earned fees from the REIT and owned the property manager, which also earned fees. The second respondent, Quarz Capital Asia (Singapore) Pte Ltd, held about 14% of the units and drove an effort to internalise management. At an EGM on 7 August 2023, unitholders passed ordinary resolutions to remove the external manager and direct the trustee, HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Singapore) Ltd, to set up an internal manager.

The trustee considered that amendments to the trust deed, requiring an extraordinary resolution, were needed to implement this. Quarz contended that the ESR Entities could not vote on them because of a conflict-of-interest clause, Paragraph 4 of Schedule 1 to the trust deed, which barred the manager, its controlling shareholders and associates from voting on a matter in which a controlling shareholder or associate had a material interest. The trustee sought declarations in HC/OA 19/2024. The ESR Entities relied on a letter of 18 April 2024 from SGX Regulation stating that the Listing Rules did not require them to abstain. The High Court Judge held that they were barred from voting, and they appealed in Civil Appeal No 37 of 2024, also applying in AD/SUM 31/2024 to admit ESR Group Ltd's financial statements as further evidence.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether, on its proper construction, Paragraph 4 of the trust deed disqualified the ESR Entities from voting on the proposed amendments.
  2. What the terms matter and material interest in Paragraph 4 mean, and whether the interest must be extraneous to an interest as unitholder.
  3. What costs order should follow an unsuccessful beneficiary's appeal on the construction of a trust instrument.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The purpose of Paragraph 4 was to disqualify the named persons where they had an interest in the subject of the meeting material enough to influence how they voted. The word matter was deliberately broader than resolution, used elsewhere in the schedule, and meant the subject and object of the meeting: implementing internalisation to replace the external manager. The amendments needed a supermajority, so the ESR Entities' stake might allow them to block them. The material interest had to be extraneous to an interest as unitholder; while unitholders may ordinarily vote selfishly, Paragraph 4 was an agreed curtailment of that right.

The court did not decide whether the interest of one group member disqualifies all, as the point was obiter and all the ESR Entities shared the interest, though it noted reservations. It found the Judge's reliance on s 253E of the Australian Corporations Act and other extrinsic regulatory material unhelpful in construing a deed. The SGX letter did not bind the parties or the court and dealt with the Listing Rules, not the deed.

Applying Paragraph 4, removal would cost the external manager significant fees and put the property manager's fees at risk, reducing the ESR Entities' dividends; a vote against could delay that. The external manager's revenue and profit from the REIT were significant viewed objectively, and comparing them with the group's overall revenue was irrelevant. On costs, an appeal is a test of the judge's decision, so an unsuccessful beneficiary normally pays the respondents' costs.

From the judgment

“It cannot therefore be said that the ESR Entities did not have a material interest in a process meant to result in the final removal of the External Manager.”

[2024] SGHC(A) 25 at [59]

“The ESR Entities were entitled to test the Judge’s decision, but not at the expense of Quarz, the Trustee, or the other unitholders of Sabana REIT.”

[2024] SGHC(A) 25 at [67]

Step 4: The order

The Appellate Division, in grounds delivered by Kannan Ramesh JAD, allowed the application to adduce further evidence but dismissed the appeal, holding that the ESR Entities were barred from voting by Paragraph 4. The ESR Entities were ordered to pay Quarz costs of $50,000 and disbursements of $4,218, and the trustee costs of $15,000 and disbursements of $1,119.80, on a standard basis, with the trustee allowed to recover the balance of its indemnity costs from the REIT.

The order in the court's words

Appeal dismissed

“We therefore dismissed the appeal.”

Source: [2024] SGHC(A) 25, High Court (Appellate Division), decided 4 September 2024. Read directly from the judgment.

Terms in this case

Conflict of interest
A situation in which a person who owes a duty to act in another's interest, such as a lawyer, fiduciary or company director, has a personal interest, or a duty to someone else, that conflicts or may conflict with that duty.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court (Appellate Division)
Decided
Judges Debbie Ong Siew Ling, Kannan Ramesh, See Kee Oon
What the case was about Trusts, Deeds and Other Instruments
Outcome Appeal dismissed

Source: [2024] SGHC(A) 25, High Court (Appellate Division), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judges

Parties

  • E-SHANG Infinity Cayman Ltd Appellant
  • E-SHANG Jupiter Cayman Ltd Appellant
  • ESR Group Ltd Appellant
  • HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Singapore) Ltd Respondent
  • Quarz Capital Asia (Singapore) Pte Ltd Respondent

Statutes cited

Australian Corporations Act
s 253E

Cases cited (5)

SLR (1)
  • [2013] 1 SLR 374
AU (2)
  • [2006] WASCA 275
  • [2016] NSWCA 176

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC(A) 25)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer