HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Singapore) Limited v Quarz Capital Asia (Singapore) Pte. Ltd. and others

High Court

[2024] SGHC 153 · HC/OA 19/2024 · cites 6 cases (3 Singapore, 3 foreign) · cited by 2 cases

The question

Can unitholders who own a trust's external manager vote on deed amendments needed to replace it?

The answer

Not under this trust deed. The High Court declared the manager's owners prohibited from voting on the amendments needed for internalisation, as the manager's continuing fees gave them a material interest other than as unitholders.

Step 1: What happened

HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Singapore) Ltd is the trustee of Sabana Industrial Real Estate Investment Trust, a REIT listed on the SGX Mainboard and constituted by a trust deed dated 29 October 2010. The REIT was managed by an external manager wholly owned, ultimately, by ESR Group Ltd and two of its subsidiaries (the ESR Entities), which together held about 21% of the units. Quarz Capital Asia (Singapore) Pte Ltd, holding about 14%, drove a plan to internalise management by replacing the paid external manager with an internal manager owned by unitholders. Quarz claimed this would save costs and improve accountability.

At an EGM on 7 August 2023, unitholders resolved to remove the external manager and directed the trustee to effect internalisation; the external manager stayed on as interim manager. The trustee considered that the trust deed had to be amended, which needed an extraordinary resolution of at least 75% of unitholders present and voting. Quarz said the amendments were unnecessary or could be made by the trustee alone, and that the ESR Entities should in any case be barred from voting. The trustee brought Originating Application No 19 of 2024 seeking the court's guidance through six prayers. The court decided the application on 23 May 2024 with brief grounds; the ESR Entities appealed only on the voting question, and these are the full grounds.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the proposed amendments to the trust deed were required to implement internalisation
  2. Whether the trustee's power to amend the trust deed without unitholder approval under cl 28.2.1 was a discretion or an obligation
  3. Whether the ESR Entities were prohibited by Paragraph 4 of Schedule 1 to the trust deed from voting on the amendments

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The full grounds address the voting question, the only one appealed; the first three prayers were dealt with in the brief grounds, and the points on cl 28.2.1 and convening an EGM were not contested. Applying the ordinary principles of contractual interpretation to the trust deed, the court noted that Paragraph 4 bars the manager, its controlling shareholders and their associates from voting on a matter in which a controlling shareholder or associate has a material interest. It was not disputed that the ESR Entities were associates and controlling shareholders of the external manager.

The court rejected the argument that a material interest must be weighed against the ESR Entities' interest as unitholders, whose units counsel valued at about S$80m. Every unitholder has an interest as unitholder in amending the trust deed, so the material interest must be one extraneous to that interest. Drawing on the Australian equivalent, s 253E of the Corporations Act 2001, and the AMP Capital decisions, the court held that the provision had a prophylactic purpose: if any one member of the associated group has an extraneous interest, all are barred, whatever the value of their units.

The ESR Entities had such an interest. The external manager, their wholly owned subsidiary with no other significant business, kept earning fees as interim manager for as long as internalisation was delayed or frustrated, about S$4.58m in fees in 2023 and an average profit of S$1.22m a year, which the court considered substantial. The ESR Entities offered no evidence that these sums were immaterial. The SGX's view under its own listing rule did not interpret Paragraph 4 and did not bind the court. Their voting at the 2023 EGM was explained by cl 24.1.4, which expressly lets all unitholders vote on removing the manager.

From the judgment

“The “material interest” must therefore relate to an interest that is extraneous or separate from its interest qua Unitholder – ie, an interest other than as a unitholder.”

[2024] SGHC 153 at [39]

Step 4: The order

Hri Kumar Nair J made declarations that only the amendments to cl 16.4 were required to effect internalisation, that the trustee's power under cl 28.2.1 was a discretion, and that the trustee was at liberty to convene an EGM on any amendments it wished to propose, with liberty to apply for directions. The court also declared that the ESR Entities were prohibited from voting on a resolution to approve the amendments, so far as those amendments were needed to implement internalisation.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Hri Kumar Nair
What the case was about Trusts

Source: [2024] SGHC 153, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • E-SHANG Infinity Cayman Ltd Defendant
  • E-SHANG Jupiter Cayman Ltd Defendant
  • ESR Group Ltd Defendant
  • HSBC Institutional Trust Services (Singapore) Ltd Applicant
  • Quarz Capital Asia (Singapore) Pte Ltd Defendant

Counsel

Counsel for the second to fourth defendants

Statutes cited

Cases cited (6)

SG (1)
  • [2020] SGHC 106
SLR (2)
  • [1999] 3 SLR(R) 896
  • [2017] 1 SLR 219
UK (1)
  • [1967] 2 AC 291
AU (2)
  • [2016] NSWCA 176
  • [2016] NSWSC 986

Cited by (2)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Statutes interpreted in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 153)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer