Builders Hub Pte Ltd v JP Nelson Equipment Pte Ltd

High Court (Appellate Division)

[2024] SGHC(A) 28 · AD/CA 38/2023 · cites 3 cases

The question

Can a court reduce an adjudication award for a contractor's fraud that did not affect the award?

The answer

No. The Appellate Division held an adjudication determination can only be set aside or varied if affected by fraud, so the reduction of $155,160 was wrong, and allowed the main contractor's appeal.

Step 1: What happened

JP Nelson Equipment Pte Ltd (JPN) engaged Builders Hub Pte Ltd (BH) as main contractor to build an office/dormitory and a factory with office at 28 Benoi Road; the contract was awarded on 8 June 2018. On 20 May 2022 BH served Payment Claim No 37 (PC 37) for $2,287,156.69 including GST. JPN's response, which the court called IV 37, certified $329,284.98 as payable. BH applied for adjudication on part of the balance of the variation works claimed.

On 4 August 2022 the adjudicator awarded BH $847,381.92 (the AA), a figure that included the $329,284.98 under IV 37. On review, the review adjudicator removed that sum on 12 September 2022 because JPN had already paid it, and the net amount became $518,096.94 (the RA).

JPN applied in HC/OA 616/2022 to set aside both determinations. Shortly before the hearing it added a ground of fraud based on five documents (the Five Cappitech Documents) that purported to show BH had paid a third party for aircon equipment. JPN said it relied on them to certify a $155,160 downpayment under earlier valuations IV 31 and IV 34. The documents were false, as BH had made no such payment. The High Court Judge found BH had fraudulently submitted them, held that the AA and RA were not affected by the fraud, but still reduced the RA by $155,160. BH appealed against that reduction in Civil Appeal No 38 of 2023. BH's fraud was not disputed on appeal.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether JPN satisfied the two-stage test in Facade Solution Pte Ltd v Mero Asia Pacific Pte Ltd [2020] 2 SLR 1125 to set aside the adjudication determinations for fraud under s 27(6)(h) of the SOPA.
  2. Whether the Judge erred in reducing the amount under the review determination by $155,160 even though neither determination was affected by the fraud.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the first issue, the court agreed with the Judge that neither the AA nor the RA was affected by the fraud. PC 37 was in substance a progress claim for one month, despite its reference period. The substance of the aircon claim in PC 37 was 5%, since 70% had already been claimed and paid. That 5% had been approved by JPN in IV 37, so it was never something to be adjudicated, and it belonged to the original contract works rather than the variation works that were the subject of the adjudication.

On the second issue, the court held that it was not open to the Judge to reduce the RA on the footing that fraud unravels everything. Under the SOPA scheme an adjudication determination has temporary finality and may only be set aside or varied if it was affected by fraud. Reducing an award that was not so affected would make the words of s 27(6)(h) otiose. The court also found that JPN had not proved the quantum of its loss: the Judge had found JPN lacked evidence for its claim that the unsupplied equipment was worth roughly 54% of the aircon contract sum, yet reduced the RA by the full $155,160 anyway.

The court stressed that it disapproved of BH's fraud and that JPN remained free to pursue BH, which is now in liquidation, for overpayment, by agreement with the liquidators or by court order. Because $518,096.94 had already been released to BH after the RA, JPN could not set its claim off against that sum.

From the judgment

“Under that scheme, an adjudication determination (whether original or upon review) has temporary finality and can only be set aside (or varied) if it is affected by the fraud.”

[2024] SGHC(A) 28 at [20]

“Hence, this is not a case where a fraudulent person is allowed to keep the fruits of the fraud.”

[2024] SGHC(A) 28 at [23]

Step 4: The order

The Appellate Division, in an ex tempore judgment delivered by Woo Bih Li JAD, allowed BH's appeal and set aside the reduction of $155,160. It ordered JPN to return to BH forthwith the $23,668.05 it had garnished; JPN's request for a stay pending arbitration was refused. BH was awarded costs of the appeal fixed at $20,000 inclusive of disbursements, and the Judge's costs order was replaced by an order that JPN pay BH's costs below fixed at $17,000 all in.

Terms in this case

Adjudication determination
The decision of an adjudicator on a payment claim under Singapore's security of payment law for the building industry. It must be paid promptly, but the underlying dispute can still be finally decided later in court or arbitration.
Adjudicator
Under Singapore's security of payment law for the building industry, the person appointed to decide a payment dispute quickly between parties to a construction contract, mainly on documents and within short fixed time limits.
Payment claim
A claim for a progress payment that a contractor or supplier serves under Singapore's security of payment law for the building industry. It starts the statutory process, and the other party must answer with a payment response within set time limits.
Security of payment
The scheme under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act that gives those who carry out construction work or supply goods or services for it a right to progress payments and a fast adjudication process when payment is disputed.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court (Appellate Division)
Decided
Judges Kannan Ramesh, See Kee Oon, Woo Bih Li
What the case was about Building and Construction Law

Source: [2024] SGHC(A) 28, High Court (Appellate Division), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Statutes cited

Cases cited (3)

SLR (2)
  • [2013] 3 SLR 380
  • [2020] 2 SLR 1125

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC(A) 28)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer