BTHMB Holdings Pte. Ltd. v Kim Byung Gun

High Court

[2024] SGHC 197 · HC/S 629/2019 ( HC/SUM 4105/2022 ) · cites 6 cases

The question

Can a court declare that a person ordered to account for money failed to give a proper account?

The answer

Yes. The High Court granted the declaration that the defendant had not given a proper, complete and accurate account of the sale proceeds, and awarded indemnity costs because his conduct in providing the account was so unreasonable.

Step 1: What happened

In an earlier judgment, BTHMB Holdings Pte Ltd v Kim Byung Gun [2023] 4 SLR 449, the High Court ordered the defendant, Dr Kim Byung Gun, to give the plaintiff, BTHMB Holdings Pte Ltd (BTHMB), an account of what became of US$22,596,913.76 in proceeds from the sale of BXA Coin cryptocurrency with which he had been entrusted. Dr Kim could rely on his expert Mr Wong's tracing opinion that US$18,490,836.92 had been paid to BTHMB as part of the Defence Transactions, leaving a shortfall of US$4,106,076.84 still to be accounted for.

Under Summons No 4105 of 2022 in Suit No 629 of 2019, directions were given for the account. Dr Kim gave documents, affidavits and oral evidence at a hearing. BTHMB then sought a declaration that he had breached his duty to account, and indemnity costs with a certificate for three solicitors. BTHMB criticised the account on several fronts: Dr Kim gave no documents for US$557,050.77 he said came from sales by a broker called Harbour; the bank records for the sums said to have gone to BTHMB did not name transferors or transferees; and for the US$4,106,076.84 he said went to other personal accounts and his personal expenses, he gave no proof of living expenses, no receipts for hospital account payments, and no full tracing of legal fees. Dr Kim accepted he should pay costs but resisted the declaration and argued for standard costs.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether Dr Kim had provided a proper, complete and accurate account of the Sale Proceeds.
  2. Whether a declaration should be granted, given Dr Kim's objections on scope and utility.
  3. Whether costs should be on an indemnity basis with a certificate for three solicitors, and in what amount.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Dr Kim's closing submissions did not substantively rebut BTHMB's criticisms; he maintained that the Harbour money went on staff welfare, bonuses and lawyers without receipts, relied on Mr Wong's report, and said he had accounted for the balance to the best of his recollection. The judge accepted BTHMB's reasons and found the account fell short of the standard of a complete, proper and accurate account with sufficient supporting evidence.

The objections to the declaration failed. The summons was not limited to finding whether Dr Kim had profited beyond the interest awarded; another purpose was for BTHMB to learn what had become of its money, so the court could resolve whether a proper account had been given. A declaration also had utility: there was a real controversy, a public interest in upholding court orders, and the question bore on costs.

On costs, the judge found Dr Kim's conduct of the accounting so unreasonable as to justify indemnity costs. A distinction was drawn between disputing liability at trial, where indemnity costs had not been awarded, and failing to account properly after being found liable. BTHMB had pointed out that Dr Kim began proper inquiries with banks only around 20 October 2023, although the earlier judgment was issued on 26 August 2022. Because he fell short, BTHMB incurred extra costs tracing the money. The work of pressing for a better account and analysing what was provided made more than two solicitors reasonably necessary. Dr Kim argued for no more than S$70,000 but did not suggest a figure if an uplift applied; the judge found the claimed S$245,000 reasonable.

From the judgment

“A distinction may be drawn between Dr Kim disputing liability at trial (for which BTHMB was not awarded indemnity costs) and Dr Kim failing to provide a proper, complete, and accurate account after trial, when he had already been found liable to account.”

[2024] SGHC 197 at [26]

Step 4: The order

Andre Maniam J granted the declaration sought, declaring that Dr Kim had not provided a proper, complete and accurate account of what became of the Sale Proceeds. BTHMB was awarded costs on an indemnity basis and a certificate of costs for three solicitors, and Dr Kim was ordered to pay costs of S$245,000 and disbursements of S$56,395.37.

Terms in this case

Indemnity costs
A basis for assessing the legal costs one party must pay another that is more generous than the usual standard basis: any doubt about whether a cost was reasonable is resolved in favour of the receiving party. It is often ordered for unreasonable conduct or where a contract provides for it.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Andre Maniam
What the case was about Equity, Civil Procedure

Source: [2024] SGHC 197, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • BTHMB Holdings Pte Ltd Plaintiff
  • Kim Byung Gun Defendant

Counsel

Counsel for the defendant

Cases cited (6)

SG (3)
  • [2017] SGHC 90
  • [2018] SGHC 267
  • [2022] SGHC 4
SLR (3)
  • [2022] 1 SLR 434
  • [2023] 1 SLR 35
  • [2023] 4 SLR 449

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 197)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer