DFD v DFE and another

High Court Registrar

[2024] SGHCR 7 · HC/OA 222/2023 ( HC/SUM 643/2024 ) · cites 15 cases · cited by 2 cases

The question

Can breaching an unless order on document production end a bid to enforce an arbitral award?

The answer

Yes. The court found the claimant had not produced WeChat messages it was treated as still holding nor properly accounted for their loss, an intentional and contumelious breach, so it allowed the application and dismissed the enforcement case.

Step 1: What happened

The claimant applied in HC/OA 222/2023 to enforce a foreign arbitral award under s 29 of the International Arbitration Act 1994, and obtained permission in HC/ORC 1189/2023. The award, made in January 2023 by a tribunal at the Beihai Court of International Arbitration (BCIA), adjudged the claimant to have rights to shares in SMCP SA held by the second respondent, a Luxembourg company. According to the claimant, those shares had been pledged under a guarantee whose arbitration clause named the Jining Arbitration Commission, later varied by a memorandum to the BCIA. The second respondent had also pledged some 28m of its shares under bonds on which it defaulted.

In February 2023 the second respondent was declared bankrupt in Luxembourg, and an officer akin to a liquidator (the Liquidator) took over its affairs. In HC/SUM 952/2023 the Liquidator sought to set aside ORC 1189, contending that the arbitration agreement was invalid and that the arbitration had been orchestrated so the claimant could get ahead of other creditors. The Liquidator obtained an order for the claimant to produce seven categories of documents, and when production was said to be incomplete, an unless order on 28 February 2024. That order required full production, inspection, and an affidavit explaining any loss of possession or control of responsive documents.

On 4 March 2024 the claimant filed a further list and an affidavit of its deputy general manager, Zhang. She said the variation was agreed at an in-person meeting in April 2022, that the parties mainly talked in person, by telephone and on WeChat, and that relevant WeChat messages were lost when two representatives, Wang and Liang, changed their mobile phones. In HC/SUM 643/2024 the Liquidator applied for the unless order to take effect, so that ORC 1189 would be set aside and OA 222 dismissed.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the claimant breached the unless order by failing fully to comply with the production order
  2. Whether the claimant gave a sufficient explanation of how and when it lost possession or control of the WeChat messages, and whether it allowed proper inspection
  3. Whether any breach was intentional and contumelious
  4. Whether letting the unless order take effect was disproportionate given its effect on enforcement of the award

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Applying the framework in DNG FZE v PayPal Pte Ltd [2024] SGHC 65, the court treated the claimant's affidavit as conclusive unless there was a reasonable suspicion, or it was plain and obvious, that further documents existed. The claimant's silence on what mode of communication was used on the key occasions was curious, but could not on affidavits alone found a finding that other written records existed. However, a screenshot of a 30 December 2022 message supplied by the arbitration lawyer of the second respondent showed that more such messages existed and that the claimant could obtain them, so production was incomplete.

The explanation for the lost messages was insufficient. A party ordered to explain a loss must say how and when it happened. The claimant did not say why the messages could not be read on the old phones, when the phones were changed, or why the messages could not be had from others who attended the meeting. It was therefore treated as still holding them. Supplying printed copies of documents already sent electronically, rather than the originals, also breached the inspection requirement.

The claimant offered no meaningful explanation and had a prior record of persistent non-compliance, so the breaches were intentional and contumelious and proportionality applied only in a limited way.

Giving effect to the order did not offend minimal curial intervention or s 31(1) of the Act, which limits the grounds for refusing enforcement in a challenge to the award, not ordinary procedural remedies. The missing documents went to two of the three grounds in SUM 952, which could not otherwise be fairly heard. A further chance to comply was refused as pointless given the claimant's fixed position.

From the judgment

“After all, what is required of the producing party is to “explain” the circumstances in which it lost P&C and not merely “state” so.”

[2024] SGHCR 7 at [73]

“The extent to which a party is required to comply with procedural rules and court orders cannot be contingent on the remedy it seeks.”

[2024] SGHCR 7 at [104]

Step 4: The order

The Assistant Registrar allowed SUM 643, ordered that the unless order take effect, set aside ORC 1189 and dismissed OA 222. No order was made on SUM 952, which had become nugatory. The claimant was ordered to pay the Liquidator $12,000 in costs and $3,307.89 in disbursements for SUM 643, $40,000 for the costs of SUM 952 and $9,000 for an earlier evidence application, plus the disbursements of those applications. No order was made on the costs of OA 222.

Terms in this case

Arbitral award
The decision of an arbitral tribunal on the dispute or part of it. It binds the parties, can be enforced with the court's permission like a court judgment, and can be set aside only on limited grounds.
Production of documents
Making relevant documents available to the other party or the court for inspection. Under the current Rules of Court, it is the name for the process formerly called discovery, under which parties must produce documents they rely on and those that harm their own case.
Affidavit
A written statement of facts that a person swears or affirms to be true, used as evidence in court proceedings. Making a false statement in an affidavit can be a criminal offence.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court Registrar
Decided
Judge Perry Peh
What the case was about Civil Procedure

Source: [2024] SGHCR 7, High Court Registrar, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Statutes cited

Cases cited (15)

SG (6)
SLR (9)
  • [2002] 1 SLR(R) 604
  • [2006] 3 SLR(R) 174
  • [2008] 4 SLR(R) 1
  • [2011] 4 SLR 305
  • [2013] 3 SLR 1179
  • [2014] 4 SLR 79
  • [2015] 3 SLR 488
  • [2023] 4 SLR 903
  • [2024] 3 SLR 1502

Cited by (2)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Statutes interpreted in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHCR 7)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer