Ayaz Ahmed and others v Mustaq Ahmad @ Mushtaq Ahmad s/o Mustafa and others and another matter

High Court

[2026] SGHC 221 · HC/S 1158/2017 ( HC/SUM 710/2026 ) · HC/S 780/2018 ( HC/SUM 725/2026 ) · cites 12 cases (11 Singapore, 1 foreign)

The question

When can a court-ordered buyout valuation be set aside for manifest error or valuer bias?

The answer

Only for an obvious error admitting no difference of opinion, bias, or acting outside the order. The High Court found the plaintiffs' complaints were differences of professional opinion, none of the three grounds was made out, and dismissed both challenges.

Step 1: What happened

These two summonses arose from long-running minority oppression suits about Mohamed Mustafa & Samsuddin Co Pte Ltd (MMSCPL), the company behind Mustafa Centre. The plaintiffs in Suit 1158 of 2017 are beneficiaries of the estate of Mustafa s/o Majid Khan, and the plaintiffs in Suit 780 of 2018 are beneficiaries of the estate of Samsuddin s/o Mokhtar Ahmad. Both estates are shareholders of MMSCPL. In Ayaz Ahmed v Mustaq Ahmad [2022] SGHC 161 the court found several acts of oppression by directors and ordered the first and second defendants, Mustaq Ahmad and his wife Ishret Jahan, to buy out the two estates' shareholdings (25.4% and 25.7%) at a price to be fixed by an independent valuer. The Appellate Division largely upheld that decision in Mustaq Ahmad v Ayaz Ahmed [2024] 1 SLR 1016 and allowed the Suit 780 plaintiffs' appeal in part, adding further oppressive acts.

On 14 January 2022 the court appointed Mr James Nicholson of FTI Consulting as the valuer. The buyout order allowed parties a round of submissions, a draft report and a further round of submissions. It said the valuation could be challenged only if it did not follow the buyout order, was patently or manifestly in error, or was tainted by fraud, corruption, collusion, dishonesty, bad faith or bias. The valuer's report of 18 March 2024 valued MMSCPL's equity at $646.7m as at 16 August 2021 before adjusting for the oppressive acts. After the appeal, a supplementary report of 5 March 2025 kept that figure, added the effect of all the oppressive acts and share allotments, and valued the two shareholdings at $253,070,093 and $256,059,110. The respondents paid in stages and, according to the court, had paid more than half a billion dollars in total.

On 5 March 2026 both sets of plaintiffs filed summonses (SUM 710 and SUM 725) challenging only the $646.7m base valuation, relying on all three grounds and on reports by their expert, Mr Andre Toh of EY. They asked for the valuation to be varied upwards by a different valuer. The respondents relied on a report by Mr Timothy Reid of Baker Tilly.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the valuer's findings, including his forecast of a 10-year decline in revenue, his valuation of the properties and his treatment of related parties' use of company assets, were manifest errors.
  2. Whether a challenge on the bias ground required actual bias or apparent bias, and whether the valuer acted in a quasi-judicial capacity.
  3. Whether, on either threshold, the valuer's conduct showed bias against the plaintiffs.
  4. Whether the valuer acted outside the terms of the buyout order, including by relying on a property consultant's valuation or failing to arrive at a fair value.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On manifest error, the court applied the principles in Viking Engineering and Geowin. A manifest error must be obvious, capable of affecting the result and admit of no difference of opinion. Failing to consider relevant matters, taking irrelevant matters into account, errors of judgment and even negligent valuations do not qualify. Following Teo Lay Gek v Hoang Trong Binh [2019] SGHC 84, the court held that the plaintiffs' complaints were differences in professional opinion between Mr Toh and the valuer. It also rejected an alleged arithmetical error, since the report explained that figures in the text had been rounded.

The court then went through the nine complaints. The valuer's refusal to split department store and supermarket sales rested on his view that the internal spreadsheet relied on was unreliable and could not be reconciled with the audited accounts. Using FY2015 to FY2019, and leaving out the pandemic years, was a reasoned choice, and the 3% decline he adopted favoured the plaintiffs more than the 11% decline of the earlier period would have. Using one Indian retailer, V-Mart, as the only comparable in a high-level market cross-check was explained, and the standards relied on only described several comparables as preferred. His finding that the 2017 closure of the Serangoon Plaza outlet had no discernible effect was based on analysis of revenue per square foot and the overall trend. His views on online retail, on the lack of plans to sell online and on the lack of plans to expand overseas were inferences he was entitled to draw, given that later developments did not show the company's intentions at the valuation date. Relying on OrangeTee for the property valuations, after considering the plaintiffs' expert RKCO and putting RKCO's criticisms to OrangeTee, was within his discretion. The choice between nearby conservation shophouses and more distant shopping centres as comparables was a matter of professional judgment. His treatment of trademark use, of a related distributor and of employees who worked for several companies was explained and proportionate.

On bias, the court held that the valuer acted as an expert, not in a quasi-judicial role. Drawing on Evergreat Construction Co Pte Ltd v Presscrete Engineer Pte Ltd [2006] 1 SLR(R) 634 and on the terms of the buyout order, it noted that he could act inquisitorially, use his own expertise, decide his own procedure and was not bound by the parties' submissions. The court had also confirmed his discretion at a hearing on 7 August 2023. Since the plaintiffs' case for an apparent bias test depended on a quasi-judicial role, and they did not allege actual bias, the ground failed. Even on an apparent bias test, a fair-minded observer would not suspect bias: the valuer gave reasons throughout and made several decisions in the plaintiffs' favour, including considering a sale-and-leaseback scenario that raised the value by about $90m.

On excess of mandate, the court found no abdication of responsibility and held that relabelling disagreements on the merits as a failure to reach a fair value would allow backdoor appeals, contrary to the limited grounds in the order. Taken together, the complaints still did not change their character.

From the judgment

“if an expert answers the right question in the wrong way his decision will nevertheless be binding”

[2026] SGHC 221 at [33]

“An alleged error in respect of the merits of the valuation does not become an excess of mandate merely because it is relabelled as a “failure to arrive at a fair value”.”

[2026] SGHC 221 at [50]

“disagreements with the Valuer’s reasoned exercise of professional judgment do not transform into a manifest error merely because there are numerous such disagreements”

[2026] SGHC 221 at [186]

Step 4: The order

Mavis Chionh Sze Chyi J dismissed both SUM 710 and SUM 725, finding that the plaintiffs had failed to make out any of the three grounds of challenge to the valuation. The court said it would hear the parties on costs.

Terms in this case

Apparent bias
A ground for setting aside a decision where a fair-minded and informed observer, knowing the relevant facts, would reasonably suspect that the decision-maker was not impartial, even if no actual bias is shown.
Oppression
In company law, a claim under section 216 of the Companies Act 1967 by a member or debenture holder that the company's affairs are being conducted, or directors' powers used, oppressively, in disregard of their interests, or in a way unfairly prejudicial to them. The court may then make wide orders, such as a share buy-out.
Trade mark
A sign, such as a word, logo or shape, used to distinguish one trader's goods or services from those of others. Registration under the Trade Marks Act 1998 gives the owner exclusive rights to use it and to sue for infringement; an unregistered mark relies mainly on passing off.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Mavis Chionh Sze Chyi
What the case was about Professions

Source: [2026] SGHC 221, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

Counsel

Counsel for the Providentia Wealth Management (watching brief)
Counsel for the defendant

Cases cited (12)

SG (5)
  • [2015] SGHC 222
  • [2019] SGHC 84
  • [2020] SGHC 78
  • [2021] SGHC 286
  • [2022] SGHC 161
SLR (6)
  • [2006] 1 SLR(R) 634
  • [2007] 1 SLR(R) 1004
  • [2012] 4 SLR 738
  • [2018] 2 SLR 1156
  • [2021] 1 SLR 497
  • [2024] 1 SLR 1016
UK (1)
  • [2002] 1 All ER 703

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2026] SGHC 221)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer