Credit Suisse Trust Limited v Bidzina Ivanishvili and others

Court of Appeal (International)

[2024] SGCA(I) 5 · CA/CAS 10/2023 · cites 16 cases (13 Singapore, 3 foreign) · cited by 2 cases

The question

Does a trustee that knows of unauthorised payments from trust accounts but does nothing breach a fiduciary duty?

The answer

Yes. The Court of Appeal held the trustee breached its core duty of good faith and the no-conflict rule, upheld the whole portfolio approach, and allowed the appeal only in part by adjusting the US$742.73m award.

Step 1: What happened

Credit Suisse Trust Limited (CS Trust) was trustee of the Mandalay Trust, set up with assets exceeding US$1.1bn for Mr Bidzina Ivanishvili and his family. The assets were held at Credit Suisse AG (CS Bank). Mr Patrice Lescaudron, his relationship manager at CS Bank from 2006 until 2015, had no authority over the trust accounts, yet made large unauthorised payments away, traded heavily and used the assets to cover losses in other clients' accounts; he was later convicted in Switzerland. CS Trust knew of the unauthorised payments from November 2006, when US$35.412m left the accounts, but sent only sporadic reminders and in 2012 dropped an inquiry after being told the client relationship mattered to the bank. The fraud surfaced in 2015.

In Suit No 4 of 2021, the SICC judge held that CS Trust had breached its duties by 30 March 2008 and that, had it told Mr Ivanishvili then, he would have moved the whole portfolio elsewhere. She awarded US$742.73m using a whole portfolio model measured against expert-built benchmark portfolios. CS Trust admitted breaching a duty to safeguard the assets but said it was only a tortious duty, so scope of duty principles and contributory negligence should cut its liability. It appealed in Civil Appeal No 10 of 2023.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether CS Trust breached fiduciary duties, and not merely a duty of care, despite no breach of the no-profit rule
  2. Whether the scope of duty principle and contributory negligence could limit CS Trust's liability
  3. Whether the whole portfolio model was the right measure of equitable compensation
  4. When an appellate court may revisit a trial judge's acceptance of expert evidence, and whether specific benchmark assumptions should change

Step 3: How the court reasoned

The court rejected the argument that fiduciary duties are limited to the no-profit and no-conflict rules. Following Tan Yok Koon v Tan Choo Suan and another and other appeals [2017] 1 SLR 654, an express trustee owes a core fiduciary duty to perform the trust honestly and in good faith for the beneficiaries. That duty governs how other duties are performed and can itself require action where the trustee knows the beneficiaries are at risk; it targets disloyalty, not incompetence. CS Trust knew the payments were unauthorised and harmful yet did nothing for years, breaching it in both senses. It also put Credit Suisse's business interests first, breaching the no-conflict rule, which had been sufficiently pleaded.

As the breach was fiduciary and non-custodial, equitable compensation applied under Sim Poh Ping v Winsta Holding Pte Ltd and another and other appeals [2020] 1 SLR 1199. Once loss was shown, causation was presumed and CS Trust bore the burden of showing the loss would have happened anyway. Counsel for CS Trust conceded that the scope of duty principle applies only to the tortious duty of care, and the court doubted that contributory negligence fits fiduciary breaches.

The whole portfolio model was upheld because Mr Ivanishvili would have moved everything and the portfolio was tainted as a whole. It was not a windfall, since both sides' models relied on benchmark returns and his own investments were excluded.

On experts, appellate courts generally respect such findings, but where the evidence lies mainly in written reports the appellate court can scrutinise them, and opinion must fit the objective facts about the particular investor. The court therefore excluded hedge funds by default, since Mr Ivanishvili admitted authorising them, save categories shown to be fraudulent or unsuitable. It preferred Ms Mayr's allocation, reflecting his actual appetite for alternative investments, her use of the HFRX index named in the mandate, and her single global index, which Mr Morrey accepted was equally valid. Management fees were required because the counterfactual assumed an active manager. The judge's other choices, including the 31 March 2008 start date and total return indices, were upheld.

From the judgment

“Breaches of fiduciary duties are those that connote disloyalty — mere incompetence is not enough”

[2024] SGCA(I) 5 at [49]

Step 4: The order

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal only in part. The finding of breach of fiduciary duty and the whole portfolio approach were upheld, but the court ordered adjustments to the US$742.73m award. Hedge fund investments were to be excluded from the portfolio except three identified categories. Ms Mayr's asset allocation, alternative investment indices and single global equity index were to be used for the relevant accounts. Portfolio management fees were to be deducted from Mr Morrey's ETF-based benchmark portfolios. The parties were to work out the revised award with their experts, with liberty to apply. The respondents, as the more successful party, were awarded appeal costs fixed at $80,000 plus reasonable disbursements.

The order in the court's words

Appeal allowed in part

“In conclusion, we allow the appeal but only in part.”

Source: [2024] SGCA(I) 5, Court of Appeal (International), decided 5 July 2024. Read directly from the judgment.

Terms in this case

Fiduciary duty
A duty of loyalty owed by a person who has undertaken to act for another in a relationship of trust and confidence, such as a trustee, company director or agent. It requires acting in good faith, not profiting from the position without consent and avoiding conflicts of interest.
Causation
The requirement that a person's conduct actually brought about the loss or result complained of: generally, that it would not have happened but for that conduct, and that no new intervening act broke the chain; it applies in tort, contract and criminal law.
Contributory negligence
A claimant's own failure to take reasonable care for their safety, which helped cause the harm. Damages are then reduced in proportion to the claimant's share of the blame. In sentencing for driving offences, a victim's own carelessness that affected the degree of the offender's negligence may reduce the offender's culpability.
Expert evidence
Opinion evidence from a person with specialised knowledge gained through training, study or experience, given to help the court on matters outside ordinary knowledge. Under the Evidence Act 1893 such opinion is relevant, but the court decides how much weight to give it, and an expert owes a duty to assist the court impartially.

Court record

Key facts

Court Court of Appeal (International)
Decided
Judges Andrew Phang Boon Leong, Robert French, Steven Chong
What the case was about Equity, Evidence
Outcome Appeal allowed in part

Source: [2024] SGCA(I) 5, Court of Appeal (International), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Cases cited (16)

SLR (13)
  • [2010] 1 SLR 1129
  • [2012] 4 SLR 339
  • [2014] 3 SLR 329
  • [2016] 2 SLR 944
  • [2017] 1 SLR 654
  • [2017] 2 SLR 592
  • [2018] 1 SLR 180
  • [2020] 1 SLR 1199
  • [2022] 1 SLR 1240
  • [2022] 1 SLR 302
  • [2023] 1 SLR 1648
  • [2023] 5 SLR 59
  • [2024] 3 SLR 78
UK (3)
  • [1997] 1 AC 191
  • [1998] Ch 1
  • [2021] 3 WLR 81

Cited by (2)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA(I) 5)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer