True Yoga Pte Ltd and others v Patrick John Wee Ewe Seng

High Court

[2024] SGHC 228 · HC/S 376/2019 · cites 6 cases

The question

After a fiduciary breaches the duty of good faith, who must prove the loss would have happened anyway?

The answer

The fiduciary. The High Court held that once a breach of a core fiduciary duty and a loss are shown, he must prove the loss would have occurred anyway, and ordered the experts to agree the figure on its parameters.

Step 1: What happened

The plaintiffs, True Yoga Pte Ltd and two related companies, operate gyms and fitness centres in Singapore as part of the True Group. The defendant, Mr Patrick John Wee Ewe Seng, was the group's chief executive officer from 19 March 2008 until 9 May 2018 and a director of the plaintiffs. The group's Thailand and Malaysia operations ceased on 9 June 2017 and 10 June 2017. In earlier proceedings in Suit No 376 of 2019, he was found liable for breaching his contractual and director's duties, and the Appellate Division characterised the loss as financial loss from damage to the brand equity of the True brand.

This judgment dealt with quantifying that loss. Both accounting experts agreed the loss should be measured as lost cash sales less expenses. The plaintiffs' expert put the loss between S$5.863m and S$13.852m depending on which of 12 permutations was adopted, while the defendant's expert put it at S$284,280. They differed on the benchmark for expected sales, the period of loss, the treatment of expenses, and the effect of changes to the plaintiffs' membership and pricing structures.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. How uncertainties in quantifying the loss should be resolved where a fiduciary has breached his duty of good faith
  2. Whether expected cash sales should be measured against the internal budgets or historical performance, and over what period
  3. Whether changes in membership plans, pricing and instalment payment options, rather than the breach, caused the lost sales

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the burden, the court applied Sim Poh Ping and Credit Suisse: once a breach of a core fiduciary duty and a loss are shown, the fiduciary is presumed to have caused the loss and must prove it would have occurred anyway. The defendant's breach of his duty of good faith was undisputed, and the plaintiffs were taken to have elected equitable compensation.

On the benchmark, the budgets were unreliable because actual sales for February to May 2017 were between 13% and 19% below budget, well beyond the 5% the experts agreed was material, and there was no later data to test the budget over the year. The historical benchmark avoided assuming growth that the evidence did not show. The court preferred a direct comparison with the preceding year to capture seasonality, with a downward adjustment for a competitor's closure in mid-2016. Membership sales fell from July 2017 to June 2018, and new member sales dropped sharply after the closures were announced, supporting a 12-month period; the documents relied on by each side were too general to show how long the impact lasted.

On the alternative causes, the defendant had not shown that the switch from a 2-year plan to a 1+1 plan drove the decline, since sales stayed low after the 2-year plan returned and the share of customers using instalments was uncertain. He did not prove any policy to stop selling 36-month memberships, which continued to sell. The end of a bank's instalment service did not reduce new member sales. The shift to Dues Plus Memberships changed only the timing of receipts, not the amount, so it was no loss, and the plaintiffs' expert's proxy adjustment, which included reductions in the plaintiffs' loss, was reasonable even if not perfect.

From the judgment

“There is no reason to assume that the plaintiffs’ Cash Sales would have grown had the defendant not breached his fiduciary duty.”

[2024] SGHC 228 at [17]

Step 4: The order

The High Court set the parameters for quantifying the plaintiffs' loss and ordered the parties to instruct their experts to agree the figure on that basis, with liberty to apply if no agreement was reached. It adopted the historical benchmark using the plaintiffs' approach, included monthly membership income, adopted a 12-month loss period from July 2017 to June 2018, accepted the plaintiffs' treatment of expenses, and adopted the plaintiffs' expert's adjustment for the shift to Dues Plus Memberships. Costs were to be heard later.

Terms in this case

Fiduciary duty
A duty of loyalty owed by a person who has undertaken to act for another in a relationship of trust and confidence, such as a trustee, company director or agent. It requires acting in good faith, not profiting from the position without consent and avoiding conflicts of interest.
Assessment of damages
The stage of a civil case at which the court works out how much money is to be paid as damages, often held separately after liability has already been decided and frequently heard by a registrar.
Causation
The requirement that a person's conduct actually brought about the loss or result complained of: generally, that it would not have happened but for that conduct, and that no new intervening act broke the chain; it applies in tort, contract and criminal law.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Choo Han Teck
What the case was about Damages

Source: [2024] SGHC 228, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

Counsel

Counsel for the defendant

Cases cited (6)

SLR (4)
  • [2010] 1 SLR 286
  • [2020] 1 SLR 1199
  • [2023] 2 SLR 323
  • [2023] 5 SLR 445

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 228)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer