Li Jialin and another v Wingcrown Investment Pte Ltd

Court of Appeal

[2024] SGCA 48 · CA/CA 5/2024 · cites 16 cases (9 Singapore, 7 foreign) · cited by 1 case

The question

Can a property developer forfeit part of an unreasonably large deposit when buyers fail to complete?

The answer

No. The Court of Appeal held a deposit of almost 63% of the price was not a true deposit and could not be forfeited at all, though the option fee could be kept; it allowed the buyers' appeal.

Step 1: What happened

Li Jialin and Li Suinan agreed in 2015 to buy an apartment in The Crest from the developer, Wingcrown Investment Pte Ltd, for $1,785,000. They defaulted on instalments from September 2016 and the developer terminated that first agreement. The parties then agreed a second option to purchase at $1,900,000. Under it, $357,000 that would otherwise have been forfeited was credited as the option fee, and a refund amount due from the first deal was credited towards the deposit. The resulting sale terms defined the deposit as $1,195,354.42, almost 63% of the price, and incorporated the Law Society's Conditions of Sale 2012, whose Condition 15.9(c)(i) lets a vendor "forfeit and keep any deposit paid" if a notice to complete is not met.

The buyers exercised the option on 30 April 2018 but did not complete, and on 20 November 2018 the developer terminated and asserted a right to forfeit the whole deposit. It refused requests for a refund in 2019 and resold the flat in 2021. After a letter of demand in March 2023, the developer changed its stance, saying it would forfeit $380,000, or 20% of the price, keep further sums for expenses, and refund $488,957.04. The buyers applied to recover the whole deposit. The High Court judge held the developer could forfeit $380,000 as a reasonable deposit and sent its expense claims to an assessment. The buyers appealed in Civil Appeal No 5 of 2024.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether Condition 15.9(c)(i) let the developer choose to forfeit a reduced part of the deposit
  2. Whether the framework in Hon Chin Kong v Yip Fook Mun for deposits should be affirmed or revised
  3. Whether the developer could keep the $357,000 option fee even though it could not forfeit the deposit
  4. From when, and at what rate, interest should run on the sums withheld

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On Condition 15.9(c)(i), the court read "any deposit" as the whole amount paid as a deposit, not any part of it. A discretion to pick a smaller sum would not serve the earnest purpose of a deposit and would only let a vendor try to rescue an unreasonable one after the fact. The court also found, against the judge's view, that the developer had in fact claimed the entire deposit in 2018; its later 2023 reduction was contrived. A vendor may forfeit less as a matter of goodwill, but reasonableness is judged at the time of contracting.

On the framework, the court traced the separate histories of deposits and penalties and, with help from independent counsel Professor Yeo Tiong Min, held that deposits are sui generis and outside the penalty rule, which in Singapore is limited to compensation. It restated a three-step test: is there a right to forfeit; is the sum reasonable as an earnest, usually meaning customary unless special circumstances are shown; if not reasonable, the right to forfeit is unenforceable, whether express or implied, and recovery is left to the general law. Here the 63% deposit was not justified, and the developer's own about-turn acknowledged as much, so the buyers could recover it in unjust enrichment. The developer could not invoke relief against forfeiture, which protects the party facing forfeiture.

On the option fee, pleading rules do not apply to originating applications, and the fee was earned under the option contract, whose basis had not failed. On interest, the rate is for the trial judge to fix, and nothing justified departing from the default rate.

From the judgment

“In short, the question is not how much one can forfeit, but whether one can forfeit at all.”

[2024] SGCA 48 at [3]

Step 4: The order

The Court of Appeal (Sundaresh Menon CJ, Tay Yong Kwang JCA and Steven Chong JCA) allowed the appeal. It held the deposit was not a true deposit and could not be forfeited at all, but that the developer was entitled to keep the $357,000 option fee. It ordered the developer to refund the remaining $23,000 of the withheld $380,000, with interest on the withheld sums at 5.33% per annum from 20 November 2018 to the dates of payment, and awarded the buyers $60,000 in costs for the appeal and below.

Terms in this case

Option to purchase
A contract by which a property owner, in return for an option fee, gives a prospective buyer the exclusive right to buy the property on stated terms within a fixed period. A binding contract of sale arises only when the buyer exercises the option in the manner it requires.
Penalty clause
A contract term requiring a party in breach to pay a sum that is not a genuine pre-estimate of the likely loss but is meant to deter breach. Singapore courts apply the rule only to sums payable on breach and will not enforce such a clause, leaving the innocent party to prove its actual loss.
Unjust enrichment
The basis of a claim that the defendant give back a benefit received at the claimant's expense where the law recognises a reason, such as mistake or failure of basis, that makes keeping it unjust, subject to defences such as change of position.

Court record

Key facts

Court Court of Appeal
Decided
Judges Steven Chong, Sundaresh Menon, Tay Yong Kwang
What the case was about Contract

Source: [2024] SGCA 48, Court of Appeal, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judges

Parties

Counsel

Counsel for the appellant
Independent counsel

Cases cited (16)

SLR (9)
  • [1995] 2 SLR(R) 643
  • [1998] 3 SLR(R) 1028
  • [2000] 3 SLR(R) 594
  • [2015] 5 SLR 1422
  • [2016] 3 SLR 1308
  • [2018] 3 SLR 534
  • [2021] 1 SLR 631
  • [2022] 3 SLR 252
  • [2024] 1 SLR 690
UK (5)
  • [1915] AC 79
  • [1924] AC 980
  • [1993] 2 WLR 702
  • [1993] AC 573
  • [2016] AC 1172
MY (1)
  • [1972] 1 MLJ 89
HK (1)
  • [2002] HKCFA 15

Cited by (1)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGCA 48)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer