Li Jialin and another v Wingcrown Investment Pte. Ltd.

High Court

[2024] SGHC 314 · HC/OA 423/2023 ( HC/RA 160/2024 ) · cites 18 cases (11 Singapore, 7 foreign)

The question

Must a developer give credit for sums it received when it tried to resell a unit?

The answer

Yes. The High Court held the $357,000 option fee had to be credited under the Conditions of Sale, cutting damages to nil, and alternatively the $139,650 forfeited from the next buyer, and allowed the buyers' appeal.

Step 1: What happened

Li Jialin and Li Suinan (the purchasers) twice failed to complete a purchase of a unit at The Crest from the developer, Wingcrown Investment Pte Ltd. Under a sale and purchase agreement of 28 December 2015 (SPA 1) at $1,785,000, they missed progress payments and Wingcrown annulled SPA 1 on 12 March 2018. At their request, Wingcrown then granted a fresh option (OTP 2) at $1.9m, with the $357,000 deposit under SPA 1 used as the option fee instead of being forfeited, and the contractual deposit on exercise set at $1,195,354.42. The purchasers exercised OTP 2 but could not complete, and Wingcrown terminated it on 20 November 2018.

Wingcrown then sold to Purchaser A for $1,995,000; that buyer also failed to complete and its deposit of $139,650 was forfeited. The unit was finally sold to Purchaser B for $1,980,000, completing on 14 April 2021. In HC/OA 423/2023 the purchasers sought the return of the OTP 2 deposit; the court found Wingcrown entitled in principle to an equitable set-off to be assessed, and the Court of Appeal later held in [2024] SGCA 48 that the $1,195,354.42 could not be forfeited but was recoverable subject to set-off for the option fee and damages as assessed. In the assessment, HC/AD 12/2023, an assistant registrar allowed Wingcrown $95,178.31 out of a larger sum claimed. The purchasers appealed in Registrar's Appeal No 160 of 2024.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether Wingcrown's damages claim was for liquidated damages under Condition 15 of the Law Society's Conditions of Sale 2012 or for unliquidated damages at general law
  2. Whether Condition 15.10(b) required Wingcrown to give credit for the $357,000 option fee as money paid on account of the purchase price
  3. Whether, at common law, Wingcrown had to credit benefits from its mitigation, namely the deposit forfeited from Purchaser A and the OTP 2 option fee

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the nature of the claim, the court found Wingcrown's case unclear and inconsistent. Applying Talley and Allgreen, the without prejudice words in Condition 15.9(c) give a vendor an initial choice between common law damages and its rights under the Conditions, but once it elects to use those rights it is confined to the liquidated damages they define. Wingcrown had relied on Condition 15 when terminating OTP 2 and throughout the proceedings, including to keep the deposit and the surplus from the resale, so it had elected to proceed under the Conditions for both failed sales. The court also rejected the argument that the one-year limit in Condition 15.10 did not apply to its limb (c).

On the option fee, the court held that Conditions 15.10(a) and (b) cover a resale that is contracted but not completed, since a contract includes an exercised option and the words any attempted re-sale would otherwise be pointless. OTP 2 was itself an attempted resale to the same buyers, and Condition 15.10(b) is illustrative rather than exhaustive of the loss recoverable. TG Master, which concerned an unexercised option, did not stop an option fee from being credited to the price once exercised; OTP 2 expressly credited it to the purchase price. As the fee exceeded both the sum claimed and the sum awarded, damages fell to nil.

On the common law alternative, a benefit must arise from the mitigating act itself and flow as part of a continuous transaction from the breach, not be collateral. The resale to Purchaser A arose directly from the purchasers' failure to complete: Wingcrown's own evidence showed commercial pressure to clear its inventory, OTP A was issued less than three months after OTP 2 ended, and searching for buyers is part of a developer's ordinary business, so the absence of a ready pool of buyers did not break the chain. The deposit had to be credited even against a claim framed as wasted expenses, since reliance damages remain compensatory. The OTP 2 option fee, however, was not a fresh benefit: the parties agreed not to treat it as a forfeited deposit, and following Thai Airways it was not money Wingcrown would otherwise not have received.

From the judgment

“Regardless of how a claim for damages is pleaded, it is inherent in the compensatory nature of the award that credit must be given for benefits arising from steps taken in mitigation.”

[2024] SGHC 314 at [88]

Step 4: The order

The High Court allowed the appeal. Wingcrown had to give credit for the $357,000 option fee under Conditions 15.10(a) and (b), which reduced its liquidated damages to nil; even if its claim were for unliquidated damages, it had to credit the $139,650 forfeited from Purchaser A, which exceeded the sum awarded. Either way Wingcrown was not entitled to any damages. Costs were left to be argued.

Terms in this case

Liquidated damages
A sum that a contract fixes in advance as payable if a particular breach occurs, such as a daily rate for late completion. It is enforceable if it is a genuine pre-estimate of the likely loss; a sum that is instead a penalty is not enforceable.
Sale and purchase agreement
A contract under which a seller agrees to sell, and a buyer agrees to buy, property such as land or shares, setting out the price, deposit, completion and other terms. For a unit bought from a housing developer in Singapore, the agreement follows a standard form prescribed by law.
Option to purchase
A contract by which a property owner, in return for an option fee, gives a prospective buyer the exclusive right to buy the property on stated terms within a fixed period. A binding contract of sale arises only when the buyer exercises the option in the manner it requires.
Set-off
The setting of a sum one party owes another against a sum owed in the other direction, so that only the balance is payable. Its forms include legal set-off between mutual debts, equitable set-off between closely connected claims, and set-off in insolvency, as well as set-off agreed by contract.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Kwek Mean Luck
What the case was about Damages

Source: [2024] SGHC 314, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

Counsel

Counsel for the appellant

Statutes cited

s 50(2)

Cases cited (18)

SLR (7)
  • [2000] 3 SLR(R) 594
  • [2001] 3 SLR(R) 148
  • [2005] 2 SLR(R) 302
  • [2006] 2 SLR(R) 586
  • [2010] 1 SLR 573
  • [2016] 2 SLR 1056
  • [2024] 1 SLR 690
UK (7)
  • [1912] AC 673
  • [1976] 1 WLR 459
  • [1990] 1 All ER 449
  • [2011] Ch 115
  • [2017] 1 WLR 2581
  • [2019] EWHC 150
  • [2021] 3 All ER 517

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 314)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer