Fayyaz Ahmad and another v Mustaq Ahmad @ Mushtaq Ahmad s/o Mustafa and others

High Court (Appellate Division)

[2024] SGHC(A) 17 · AD/CA 91/2021 · AD/CA 93/2021 · AD/CA 92/2021 · AD/CA 94/2021 · AD/CA 96/2021 · AD/CA 95/2021 · AD/CA 132/2021 · AD/CA 133/2021 · AD/CA 136/2021 · AD/CA 135/2021 · AD/CA 134/2021 · AD/CA 5/2022 · cites 50 cases (47 Singapore, 3 foreign) · cited by 4 cases

The question

Can paying no dividends for years while directors take large fees oppress minority shareholders?

The answer

Yes. On the prima facie standard after a no-case submission, the Appellate Division upheld the finding that paying no dividends while two directors drew substantial fees was oppressive, and allowed both sides' appeals in part.

Step 1: What happened

Mohamed Mustafa & Samsuddin Co Pte Ltd (MMSCPL) took over a family wholesale partnership and was incorporated in 1989. Its registered shareholders came to include Mustaq, his wife Ishret, Mustaq's father Mustafa and Samsuddin. After Mustafa died intestate in 2001 and Samsuddin died in 2011, the beneficiaries of their estates sued Mustaq, Ishret and Ishret's brother Iqbal (the Mustaq Group), who were directors or officers of MMSCPL. Suit 1158 of 2017 and Suit 780 of 2018 were minority oppression claims; Suit 9 of 2017 alleged that Mustaq breached his duties as administrator of Mustafa's estate, and Suit 780 also alleged breaches of his duties as executor of Samsuddin's estate.

The Mustaq Group claimed that Mustaq was the true owner of all the shares under informal common understandings reached in 1973 and 2001. They submitted that there was no case to answer and called no evidence. In Ayaz Ahmed and others v Mustaq Ahmad (alias Mushtaq Ahmad s/o Mustafa) and others and other suits [2022] SGHC 161 the trial Judge found oppression, set aside share allotments made in 1995 and 2001, and ordered Mustaq and Ishret to buy out the estates' shares at a price fixed by an independent valuer. She also found Mustaq in breach of his duties to both estates. The Mustaq Group and the beneficiaries of Samsuddin's estate appealed in Civil Appeal Nos 132 to 136 and 91 to 96 of 2021 and 5 of 2022.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the beneficiaries of Mustafa's estate had standing to bring the oppression claim
  2. Whether Mustaq beneficially owned all the shares in MMSCPL under the alleged common understandings
  3. Whether the share allotments, directors' loans, withheld dividends with large directors' fees, the alleged cashback scheme, consultancy fees, related-party credit sales and bond issue were oppressive
  4. Whether laches or acquiescence barred the claims and what relief the buy-out valuation should reflect

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Because the Mustaq Group chose to submit no case to answer, the claimants needed only a prima facie case. Mustafa's beneficiaries had standing under the Wong Moy exception, since Mustaq, the estate's administrator, would not sue himself.

The ownership claim failed. Estate duty letters, dividends and Mustaq's own correspondence treated Mustafa and Samsuddin as shareholders, and the late gift narrative exposed the common understandings as a sham. The meeting minutes said to show consent to the 1995 and 2001 allotments, which went only to Mustaq at an undervalue, were not proved authentic, and the court drew an adverse inference from Mustaq and Ishret not testifying. The 1991 and 1993 allotments were different, because Mustafa, not the Mustaq Group, was the one who benefited from them.

Interest-free loans to directors with no fixed repayment had no commercial purpose. Paying Mustaq and Ishret approximately $73.08m in directors' fees from 2001 to 2013, against only $18m in dividends declared from 2000 to 2018, was oppressive. On the prima facie standard, the court found that a scheme of collecting part of employees' declared salaries existed and that Mustaq initiated it.

The Judge had erred on the consultancy fees: the invoices were vague, payments to Mustaq's sole proprietorship called for an explanation, and none was given. The credit sales register was reliable, so the unrecorded difference of $232,935,015 was prima facie evidence that related parties had not paid. The bond claim failed for want of reliable evidence. Laches does not apply to statutory relief under s 216 of the Companies Act. Under s 41(7) of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act, the court could extend the additional findings to Mustafa's estate, because valuing the two estates' shares differently would be unjust and the Mustaq Group suffered no undue prejudice.

From the judgment

“Where a submission of no case to answer is advanced, therefore, the court is essentially left with the plaintiff’s version of the story”

[2024] SGHC(A) 17 at [93]

Step 4: The order

The Appellate Division allowed both sides' appeals in part. It allowed the Mustaq Group's appeal on the 1991 and 1993 allotments, which it held were not oppressive. It dismissed the rest of their appeal, including on the other findings of oppression, Mustaq's breaches of duty and the counterclaims. It allowed the Samsuddin estate beneficiaries' appeal on the consultancy fees and the related-party credit sales, and dismissed their appeals on the bonds, a special audit and indemnity costs. The 1996 and 1997 allotments were also set aside, so the shares are to be valued on the holdings after the allotment of 19 May 1993. The valuer is to add interest on the directors' loans, allow Mustaq a reasonable amount for his efforts in building the company, and not limit the cashback losses to the six former employees who testified. Mustafa's estate was given the benefit of the two additional findings.

Terms in this case

Oppression
In company law, a claim under section 216 of the Companies Act 1967 by a member or debenture holder that the company's affairs are being conducted, or directors' powers used, oppressively, in disregard of their interests, or in a way unfairly prejudicial to them. The court may then make wide orders, such as a share buy-out.
Prima facie case
Evidence that, if accepted and not answered, would be enough to establish a claim or charge. In a criminal trial, the court calls on the accused to give a defence only if, at the close of the prosecution's evidence, there is some credible evidence on every element of the charge.
Adverse inference
A conclusion against a party that a court may draw when the party fails, without good reason, to produce evidence, call a witness or give an explanation it could have given, such as that the missing evidence would have been unfavourable to it. Drawing it is discretionary, and the Evidence Act 1893 expressly allows it.
Laches
An equitable defence that bars or limits an equitable remedy where the claimant delayed unreasonably in pursuing it and the delay makes granting relief unjust, for example because the defendant or others changed their position meanwhile. It applies to equitable claims, generally not to claims for which the Limitation Act 1959 sets a fixed period.
Executor
A person named in a will to carry out its terms by collecting the deceased's assets, paying debts and expenses, and distributing what remains to the beneficiaries; the executor's authority comes from the will and is confirmed by a grant of probate.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court (Appellate Division)
Decided
Judges Debbie Ong Siew Ling, Kannan Ramesh, Woo Bih Li
What the case was about Companies

Source: [2024] SGHC(A) 17, High Court (Appellate Division), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judges

Parties

Statutes cited

Cases cited (50)

SG (11)
SLR (36)
  • [1991] 2 SLR(R) 114
  • [1994] 2 SLR(R) 501
  • [1995] 2 SLR(R) 304
  • [1996] 3 SLR(R) 27
  • [1999] 1 SLR(R) 773
  • [2000] 3 SLR(R) 530
  • [2005] 4 SLR(R) 417
  • [2006] 4 SLR(R) 745
  • [2006] 4 SLR(R) 95
  • [2009] 2 SLR(R) 1004
  • [2010] 2 SLR 209
  • [2010] 2 SLR 776
  • [2011] 1 SLR 582
  • [2012] 1 SLR 847
  • [2014] 4 SLR 723
  • [2015] 1 SLR 581
  • [2015] 5 SLR 1422
  • [2015] 5 SLR 307
  • [2016] 2 SLR 464
  • [2016] 5 SLR 103
  • [2017] 1 SLR 141
  • [2017] 4 SLR 1018
  • [2018] 2 SLR 333
  • [2018] 4 SLR 425
  • [2018] 5 SLR 1
  • [2019] 3 SLR 1168
  • [2019] 3 SLR 161
  • [2019] 5 SLR 366
  • [2020] 1 SLR 771
  • [2020] 2 SLR 221
  • [2020] 3 SLR 1329
  • [2021] 1 SLR 1217
  • [2021] 1 SLR 304
  • [2022] 1 SLR 136
  • [2022] 2 SLR 1250
  • [2023] 1 SLR 450
UK (1)
  • [1990] Ch 682
MY (2)
  • [1983] 2 MLJ 320
  • [2020] 5 MLJ 587

Cited by (4)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC(A) 17)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer