Sir Cornelius Sean Sullivan v Hill Capital Pte. Ltd. and another

High Court

[2024] SGHC 157 · HC/OA 820/2023 ( HC/RA 14/2024,HC/RA 15/2024 ) · cites 4 cases (2 Singapore, 2 foreign)

The question

Which law and forum govern a trustee's past conduct after the trust's proper law is changed?

The answer

Those applicable during the period concerned. The High Court held Singapore law and forum governed the trustee's conduct before the change to Cyprus, and dismissed both appeals seeking a stay.

Step 1: What happened

In 1995 Mr Joseph Sullivan created two Isle of Man trusts, The Anchor Trust and The Anchor Two Trust. Their deeds gave the trustees power to change the proper law and the forum for administration. In 2011 Hill Capital Pte Ltd, a Singapore trust company whose sole shareholder and director is Ms Ban Su Mei, became trustee of both and changed the proper law and forum to Singapore. The applicant, a purported beneficiary and the settlor's son, said he asked the respondents for trust accounts in December 2021 and March 2023 without reply, and made further requests after his father died around 29 May 2023 that he found unsatisfactory.

On 18 July 2023 Hill Capital retired as trustee of The Anchor Two Trust. A Cyprus company, Fivehill Trustees Limited, was appointed and changed that trust's proper law and forum to Cyprus. The Anchor Trust remained under Singapore law. The applicant brought HC/OA 820/2023 seeking accounts and documents and declarations that the respondents had breached their duties by not providing them, for The Anchor Two Trust only up to 18 July 2023. The respondents applied to stay the proceedings in favour of Cyprus. An Assistant Registrar dismissed the stay application, and the respondents appealed in Registrar's Appeals No 14 and 15 of 2024.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the claims for accounts and related declarations fell within the forum for administration clauses in the trust deeds.
  2. Whether claims about The Anchor Two Trust were governed by Singapore law and forum, in force when the alleged breaches occurred, or by Cyprus law and forum, in force when proceedings began.
  3. Whether Cyprus was in any event the more appropriate forum, and whether the claims on The Anchor Trust should be stayed.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Following Ivanishvili, Bidzina and others v Credit Suisse Trust Ltd [2020] 2 SLR 638, clauses of this kind govern questions in the day-to-day administration of a trust, not contentious disputes between trustees and beneficiaries. The heart of the claim was a request for documents and information about the trusts, so the claims concerned administration and fell within the clauses.

The respondents argued that, under Ivanishvili, the relevant forum was the one in place when the question arose, meaning when proceedings began. The court disagreed. Ivanishvili did not make an amended proper law apply retroactively to a trustee's earlier conduct. A trustee acts on the basis of the law and forum then applicable, and it would be grossly unfair to judge that conduct under a law unknown to it and chosen later. Questions about the running of a trust are governed by the law and forum applicable during the period they concern, which dicta in Crociani v Crociani [2014] UKPC 40 also supported. The claims on The Anchor Two Trust ended before the change, so Singapore law and forum applied. Questions such as whether the applicant was a beneficiary, whether a hostile beneficiary clause applied, or whether a retirement release barred the claim went to the merits, not to a stay. A retired trustee remains liable to account for its time in office, and the applicant could choose whom to sue. Fivehill's absence was no reason to stay, since orders against the respondents would not bind it.

Read with the definition of proper law, the clauses were exclusive jurisdiction clauses on administration questions, and there was no strong cause to depart from them. In any event Cyprus was not shown to be more appropriate: Singapore law applied, Hill Capital was a Singapore company and Ms Ban a Singapore resident. As the Anchor Two claims stayed in Singapore, there was no reason to stay the claims on The Anchor Trust.

From the judgment

“It made no sense and would be grossly unfair to the trustee for the question as to whether his conduct was wrongful to be subject to a proper law and forum for administration that was unknown to him and to be decided in the future.”

[2024] SGHC 157 at [29]

Step 4: The order

The High Court dismissed both appeals, agreeing with the Assistant Registrar that there was no reason to stay the proceedings. The respondents were ordered to pay the applicant costs fixed at $12,000 per respondent, inclusive of disbursements.

Terms in this case

Exclusive jurisdiction clause
A contract term by which the parties agree that their disputes will be decided only by the courts of a named country. A court will usually stay proceedings brought elsewhere in breach of it unless strong cause is shown.
Forum non conveniens
Latin for "an inconvenient forum": the principle that a court may stay proceedings before it, or refuse permission to serve a claim abroad, where a court in another country is clearly more appropriate to decide the dispute.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Chua Lee Ming
What the case was about Trusts, Conflict of Laws

Source: [2024] SGHC 157, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • Hill Capital Pte Ltd Respondent
  • Ban Su Mei Respondent
  • Sir Cornelius Sean Sullivan Applicant

Counsel

Counsel for the respondent
Counsel for the applicant

Cases cited (4)

SG (1)
  • [2017] SGHC 90
SLR (1)
  • [2020] 2 SLR 638
UK (2)
  • [1987] AC 460
  • [2014] UKPC 40

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 157)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer