XBO v XBP

High Court (Family Division)

[2024] SGHCF 36 · HCF/S 7/2019 · cites 25 cases (20 Singapore, 5 foreign)

The question

Does a mention of dementia mean a person could not make a valid will?

The answer

Not by itself. The High Court held serious mental illness such as dementia does not preclude testamentary capacity, found the testator had capacity for the 2012 will, and granted probate to the son.

Step 1: What happened

The plaintiff and the defendant are two of the six children of the testator, who died on 13 March 2019 leaving an estate that included a single-storey bungalow. By a will of 10 October 2011, whose validity was not challenged, he left the bungalow to the defendant. By a later will of 24 November 2012, witnessed by Mr F and Mr G, he revoked earlier wills, appointed the plaintiff sole executor and left his whole estate to the plaintiff, with his other children receiving nothing. The defendant remained in exclusive occupation of the bungalow after his death.

In HCF/S 7/2019 the plaintiff sought a pronouncement in solemn form that the 2012 will was the last true will and a grant of probate. The defendant counterclaimed for the same pronouncement in favour of the 2011 will. She did not dispute that the testator made the 2012 will, but alleged that he lacked testamentary capacity because he had been suffering from dementia or Alzheimer's disease since about January 2012, relying mainly on Changi General Hospital discharge summaries from 21, 23 and 25 November 2012 and a CT scan report of January 2012. She also pointed to circumstances she said were suspicious: the plaintiff arranged the will with an acquaintance who was a lawyer but never met the testator, chose the witnesses, and did not tell her about it. An earlier allegation of undue influence had been withdrawn.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether the testator had testamentary capacity when he executed the 2012 will
  2. Whether the hospital records and other evidence showed a mental disability negating that capacity
  3. Whether, given suspicious circumstances, the plaintiff proved the testator knew and approved of the will's contents
  4. How the costs of the probate action should be borne

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Applying Chee Mu Lin Muriel v Chee Ka Lin Caroline [2010] 4 SLR 373, the propounder bears the legal burden of proving capacity, and a serious illness such as dementia does not by itself rule capacity out. Both attesting witnesses were found honest and independent. They described the testator as lucid and alert; he conversed in Malayalam, recalled earlier meetings, and when asked why his other children were left out, said the plaintiff was his favourite son. The testator also managed his own finances, including a withdrawal of $55,871.43 in July 2012 that the defendant herself attributed to him; her shifting account of who operated the joint account was found self-serving. A draft dictated in November 2011, when capacity was not disputed, had materially the same terms. The court declined to draw an adverse inference over documents the defendant discarded, as she then knew nothing of the 2012 will.

No doctor gave evidence. The note "Alzheimers Disease ?vascular dementia" carried a question mark, the visits concerned a hernia, the final diagnoses were of hernia only, and the testator was recorded as alert. Not remembering why he called ambulances, and memory loss noted in a scan the report described as minor, did not show incapacity. The defendant's unpleaded allegations, about a dentist visit, a surprise birthday party and conversations with doctors, were unproven, and her witnesses were found unreliable or uncertain about dates.

Because the plaintiff, the sole beneficiary, arranged the will, the presumption of knowledge and approval did not arise, but the same evidence affirmatively proved it. Testamentary freedom meant the fairness of the gift was irrelevant. Since the suspicious circumstances gave the defendant reasonable grounds to challenge the will, and neither the testator nor the plaintiff was at fault, each side bore its own costs.

From the judgment

“The testator is in control of the will’s contents whether he writes it himself or dictates its contents to another person who writes it at his direction.”

[2024] SGHCF 36 at [130]

Step 4: The order

Tan Siong Thye SJ granted the plaintiff's claim, pronounced in solemn form that the 2012 will was the testator's last true will and granted probate to the plaintiff. The defendant's counterclaim was dismissed. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

Terms in this case

Testamentary capacity
The mental capacity needed to make a valid will: understanding the nature of making a will and its effect, knowing broadly the extent of one's property, appreciating the people who have claims to benefit, and having no disorder of mind that distorts those choices.
Grant of probate
An order of the court under the Probate and Administration Act 1934 that confirms a will as valid and authorises the executor named in it to administer the deceased person's estate.
Executor
A person named in a will to carry out its terms by collecting the deceased's assets, paying debts and expenses, and distributing what remains to the beneficiaries; the executor's authority comes from the will and is confirmed by a grant of probate.
Burden of proof
The obligation on a party to prove a fact to the required standard, failing which that party loses on that point. In its main sense, the legal burden, it rests on whoever asserts the fact under the Evidence Act 1893 and does not shift during the trial, unlike the evidential burden.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court (Family Division)
Decided
Judge Tan Siong Thye
What the case was about Succession and Wills

Source: [2024] SGHCF 36, High Court (Family Division), decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • XBO Plaintiff
  • XBP Defendant

Counsel

Counsel for the plaintiff
Counsel for the defendant

Cases cited (25)

SG (5)
SLR (15)
  • [1993] 3 SLR(R) 656
  • [1998] 3 SLR(R) 619
  • [2001] 3 SLR(R) 592
  • [2006] 4 SLR(R) 45
  • [2009] 3 SLR(R) 631
  • [2010] 1 SLR 52
  • [2010] 4 SLR 373
  • [2013] 4 SLR 308
  • [2014] 3 SLR 524
  • [2015] 5 SLR 1422
  • [2016] 1 SLR 595
  • [2017] 1 SLR 141
  • [2020] 1 SLR 606
  • [2021] 1 SLR 304
  • [2023] 2 SLR 235
UK (2)
  • [2011] Ch 380
  • [2013] EWHC 4097
AU (1)
  • [1999] VSC 228
MY (2)
  • [1939] 8 MLJ 100
  • [1977] 1 MLJ 15

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHCF 36)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer