Jonathan Kupetz and others v Terraform Labs Pte. Ltd. and others

Singapore International Commercial Court

[2026] SGHC(I) 25 · SIC/OA 3/2024 · cites 7 cases

The question

Can a stablecoin investor claim losses after the peg plainly failed because of a hope that it would recover?

The answer

No. The Singapore International Commercial Court held that a hope of recovery was a market prediction, not reliance, so most claimants kept the default cut-off; it allowed the claims in part and refused all aggravated damages.

Step 1: What happened

This was the third tranche of a representative action in the Singapore International Commercial Court, SIC/OA 3/2024, brought by investors who lost money when the algorithmic stablecoin TerraUSD (UST) collapsed in May 2022. The defendants were Terraform Labs Pte Ltd (TFL), which issued UST, its co-founder and chief executive Kwon Do Hyeong (Do Kwon), and Luna Foundation Guard Ltd (LFG). The defendants had conceded that certain representations about UST's stability were false and made fraudulently. Earlier judgments in the same action had found five of them actionable, fixed a default Cut-Off Time of 12.01 am UTC on 12 May 2022 (the point by which a reasonable investor would have seen the representations were false), and set a Cut-Off Price of US$0.60485 per UST.

The Third Tranche was heard from 16 June to 2 July 2026. It concerned 28 represented claimants who gave evidence, each claiming damages for UST bought in reliance on the representations, with claims ranging from US$3,049.75 to US$453,410.54. Most of them asked for a later Cut-Off Time on the basis that they still believed the peg would recover, or that travel, work, locked funds or lack of internet access stopped them from selling. Several also sought aggravated damages for mental distress. The court also had to settle the damages of three claimants left over from the second tranche, interest, and the costs of the second tranche.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether a claimant's continued hope that the peg would recover could extend the default Cut-Off Time.
  2. Whether a claimant's acceptance that UST carried some investment risk defeated reliance on the representations.
  3. Whether failing to use the UST-LUNA swap mechanism during the depeg showed a lack of reliance.
  4. Whether reliance on the Fourth Representation about Anchor alone was enough to recover damages.
  5. For each claimant, whether reliance was proved, which Cut-Off Time applied, and what damages followed.
  6. Whether any claimant proved the exceptional harm needed for aggravated damages.
  7. What pre-judgment and post-judgment interest should be awarded, and the costs of the second tranche.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

On the Cut-Off Time, the court reasoned that the conceded representations described what UST was: a coin that would always hold a 1:1 peg to the US dollar through its algorithm, arbitrage mechanism and reserve. By 11 May 2022 UST had failed to hold the peg for four days and had fallen to about US$0.2998. Once the description was plainly falsified, nothing remained in it to rely on. A belief that the mechanism was merely slow, or a hope of future recovery, was a prediction about the market, not reliance on a statement of existing fact. Work pressure, national service, family duties or being in shock were choices or personal difficulties, not a physical inability to act, so they did not justify an extension. An extension was given only where the evidence showed a claimant could not learn of the depeg or could not sell: Mr Parkhomovskyy's bus and train tickets showed he was in The Hague without his hardware wallet key; Ms Crane was at a ranch without internet; and Mr Litvin was travelling without his hardware ledger device and had funds locked in Kinetic liquidity pools released in two tranches.

The time was brought forward where a claimant sold a substantial share of holdings before the default time, which the court saw as conduct inconsistent with continued belief. Mr Hassan had sold 20,176.00 of 53,583.00 UST by 11 May 2022, and Mr Labrović sold 129,947.77 of 349,037.89 eligible UST on that day. Their losses were recalculated using the average 11 May 2022 price of US$0.80025. By contrast, Mr Yee's small sales and the decisions of Mr Sakai, Mr Justin Tan and others not to sell were treated as consistent with continued faith up to the default time.

On reliance, the test was subjective. A claimant could accept that no investment is free of risk and still rely on a representation that UST was designed to hold its value. Not using the swap mechanism proved nothing, and a fraudulent representation need only be one cause of the purchase, not the dominant one. The Anchor White Paper presented Anchor as a principal-protected stablecoin savings product, which implicitly represented that UST itself was stable against the dollar, so reliance on the Fourth Representation alone sufficed. Mr Justin Tan conceded he read only the Terra White Paper, which was not the pleaded source of the Third Representation. Recollection errors about when source documents were read were not fatal given the fast-moving digital setting.

Aggravated damages failed because the evidence did not show distress beyond ordinary financial loss, or lacked medical evidence linking the conditions to the depeg. Pre-judgment interest ran from each Cut-Off Time because the claimants sued promptly, in September 2022. Neither the Mareva injunction deposit nor the liquidation plan displaced post-judgment interest. Costs were cut because late disclosure of wallet logs and largely unsuccessful arguments for extended Cut-Off Times had driven up costs.

From the judgment

“An understanding that residual risk exists in an investment does not preclude reliance.”

[2026] SGHC(I) 25 at [21]

“The belief that the algorithm supposed to maintain the peg was not working fast enough cannot constitute reliance on the Conceded Representations as a matter of law and cannot therefore serve as a reason for extending the Cut-Off Time.”

[2026] SGHC(I) 25 at [18]

“The Fourth Representation contains a representation as to UST’s stability independently of the First to Third Representations.”

[2026] SGHC(I) 25 at [27]

Step 4: The order

The court allowed the claims in part. Every Third Tranche claimant who gave evidence was found to have relied on at least some actionable representations, but most were awarded less than they claimed. The default Cut-Off Time applied to most claimants. It was extended for Mr Parkhomovskyy (to 2.00am UTC on 14 May 2022, awarded US$15,580.36), Ms Crane (to 13 May 2022, 1.59pm UTC, awarded US$42,123.76) and Mr Litvin (staggered times for his locked holdings, awarded US$422,722.52). It was brought forward to 11 May 2022 for Mr Hassan (awarded US$10,832.44), Mr Labrović (awarded US$45,560.17) and Mr Egan, whose damages the parties were directed to agree or put in a joint memorandum within 14 days. Mr Justin Tan's reliance on the Third Representation was not established. All claims for aggravated damages were refused.

The court awarded the agreed sums to the three second-tranche claimants (Mr Kiessling US$968.77, Mr Koh US$196,938.98 and Mr Lam US$71,989.87), pre-judgment interest at 5.33% per annum from each claimant's Cut-Off Time, and post-judgment interest at 5.33% per annum from the date of judgment. Costs and disbursements for the second tranche were fixed at $1,480,361.93, after a 20% reduction from the $1,850,452.41 sought. Third Tranche costs were reserved.

Terms in this case

Aggravated damages
Extra compensatory damages awarded in tort where the manner of the wrongdoing, or the defendant's later conduct, has made the injury worse, for example by causing humiliation or distress. They compensate the claimant rather than punish the defendant.
Mareva injunction
An order that stops a defendant from moving, hiding or spending assets up to a stated value while a claim is decided, so that any judgment or award the claimant later wins can still be paid. It is usually made by a court, but an arbitral tribunal or emergency arbitrator may also make one.
Post-judgment interest
Interest that runs on a judgment debt from the date of judgment until the debt is paid, usually at a standard rate set by the courts unless the court orders otherwise.
Pre-judgment interest
Interest a court may add to a sum of money it awards, covering the period before judgment during which the successful party was kept out of the money. Whether to award it, and from when, is for the court to decide.

Featured in the weekly digest — week of 2–8 November 2026 →

Court record

Key facts

Court Singapore International Commercial Court
Decided
Judge Anselmo Reyes
What the case was about Tort, Damages

Source: [2026] SGHC(I) 25, Singapore International Commercial Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • Luna Foundation Guard Ltd Defendant
  • Terraform Labs Pte Ltd Defendant
  • Bridget Wilson Lynn Plaintiff
  • Cheong Yuen Kuen Plaintiff
  • Choy Jian Wei Plaintiff
  • Christian Denk Plaintiff
  • Danai Albert van Lith Plaintiff
  • Daniel Lance Sakai Plaintiff
  • David Francis Egan Plaintiff
  • David Micah Brooks-Smith Plaintiff
  • David Thomas Kapla Plaintiff
  • Feres Pepjin Hassan Plaintiff
  • Glen Cedric Roche Tze-Lee Plaintiff
  • Jose Noe James Seva Biron Plaintiff
  • Jure Labrović Plaintiff
  • Kupetz, Jonathan Plaintiff
  • Kwon Do Hyeong Defendant
  • Laura Jane Hewitt Plaintiff
  • Lee Yong Kang Plaintiff
  • Lip Yee Tang Plaintiff
  • Litvin Nikita Sergeevich Plaintiff
  • Loo Tian Hong Derrick Plaintiff
  • Low Chee Yong Plaintiff
  • Margaret Rose Crane Plaintiff
  • Mike Olech Plaintiff
  • Ng Wei Jie Kester Plaintiff
  • Oleksandr Mihajlovic Parkhomovskyy Plaintiff
  • Raymond Yuuki Machi Plaintiff
  • Roman Boranek Plaintiff
  • Tan Ming Kai Justin Plaintiff
  • Thomas Yuan Fang Plaintiff
  • Yee Xin Jin Joshua Plaintiff

Statutes cited

Cases cited (7)

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2026] SGHC(I) 25)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer