British and Malayan Trustees Limited v Ameen Ali Salim Talib and others

High Court

[2024] SGHC 203 · HC/OS 288/2022 · cites 20 cases (12 Singapore, 8 foreign)

The question

Can a trustee recover income overpaid to some beneficiaries out of their future trust income?

The answer

Yes. The High Court granted the trustee's application, holding it had the right to recoup the overpayments from future income, rejecting the acquiescence and estoppel defences, and sanctioning its recoupment plan as reasonable.

Step 1: What happened

British and Malayan Trustees Ltd is the sole trustee of a family trust settled in 1921 by Shaik Sallim bin Mohamed bin Sallim bin Talib, holding real estate and shares and due to expire on 26 September 2029. When a beneficiary died without issue, the trustee shared that beneficiary's income among all surviving beneficiaries (the pari passu interpretation) on legal advice. In OC 163 in 2019 the High Court held instead that the share went only to beneficiaries in the same branch of the family. As a result, income had been wrongly distributed from 21 November 2001 to November 2019, overpaying some beneficiaries and underpaying others.

In a later action, HC/OC 230/2023, underpaid beneficiaries led by Mr Lutfi and Mr Zayed sued the trustee personally. Under a settlement, the trustee paid $1,185,281.61 into the trust to cover underpayments from 2 May 2014 and agreed not to recoup overpayments from that date. That left the period from 21 November 2001 to 1 May 2014, put at $1,464,607.94. In Originating Summons No 288 of 2022 the trustee sought directions under O 80 r 2 of the Rules of Court on recouping those overpayments from future income and approval of a plan to do so over 36 months. The first to fifth respondents, representing overpaid beneficiaries, opposed; Mr Lutfi and Mr Zayed supported recoupment.

Step 2: What the court had to decide

  1. Whether it was appropriate for the trustee to seek the court's directions in these circumstances.
  2. Whether the trustee's right of recoupment was barred by acquiescence, estoppel or any other defence.
  3. Whether the trustee's proposed recoupment plan should be approved.

Step 3: How the court reasoned

Applying the four categories in Public Trustee v Cooper, the court held that whether the right of recoupment could be exercised was a question about the trustee's powers. Recoupment is rarely used and there was little local authority, the beneficiaries held entrenched opposing views, and the trustee was not neutral, having faced personal claims and potential attack whichever way it acted. Approval of the plan, a momentous and contested exercise of power, was also a proper matter for the court. The argument that the trustee had already committed against recoupment rested on a false premise.

A trustee who overpays a beneficiary may recoup the excess from that beneficiary's future entitlements, as English and Australian cases show. Once the overpayments were established, the right arose and the trustee was under a duty to exercise it as far as possible. Nothing required underpaid beneficiaries first to exhaust their remedies against the trustee; that rule concerned a beneficiary's personal claim, not the trustee's own right. Acquiescence failed because any infringed right belonged to the underpaid beneficiaries, who did not know of the error before May 2014 and induced no one. Estoppel by convention failed because a mere reduction of income the overpaid beneficiaries were never entitled to was not unconscionable. Change of position was not raised and no special circumstances existed, and recoupment, being an adjustment of accounts, is not subject to limitation.

On the plan, the court asked whether the trustee's view was one a reasonable trustee could reach, weighing the amount recoverable against cost and hardship. Spread over 36 months, the plan would cut the overpaid beneficiaries' income by about 5% or less a year on the trustee's unchallenged figures. The cost of tracing estates of deceased underpaid beneficiaries was unquantified and small beside the $1,178,810.49 to be recouped, and the trustee had undertaken not to pursue estates that could not be found without undue cost.

From the judgment

“A trustee is, and remains, under a duty to adhere to the terms of the trust, as determined by the settlor.”

[2024] SGHC 203 at [61]

Step 4: The order

Hri Kumar Nair J granted the application, ruling that the trustee had the right to recoup the overpayments for the period from 21 November 2001 to 1 May 2014 and sanctioning the proposed plan as reasonable and appropriate. By agreement, the parties' costs were ordered to be taxed and paid out of the trust.

Terms in this case

Estoppel
A rule that stops a person from going back on a position taken, by words, conduct, an agreed assumption or an earlier judgment, where it would be unjust to allow it, often because another person has relied on that position.

Court record

Key facts

Court High Court
Decided
Judge Hri Kumar Nair
What the case was about Trusts

Source: [2024] SGHC 203, High Court, decided — eLitigation. Updated .

Judge

Parties

  • British and Malayan Trustees Ltd Applicant
  • Ameen Ali Salim Talib Respondent
  • Helmi bin Ali bin Talib Respondent
  • Lutfi Salim bin Talib Respondent
  • Murtada Ali Salem Talib Respondent
  • Saadaldeen Ali Salim Talib Respondent
  • Shawqi Ali Salem Taleb Respondent
  • Zayed bin Abdul Aziz Talib Respondent

Counsel

Counsel for the applicant
Counsel for the sixth and seventh respondents
Counsel for the first to fifth respondents

Statutes cited

Cases cited (20)

SG (4)
SLR (8)
  • [2000] 3 SLR(R) 530
  • [2008] 2 SLR(R) 474
  • [2012] 1 SLR 211
  • [2014] 3 SLR 663
  • [2014] 3 SLR 904
  • [2020] 2 SLR 200
  • [2020] 5 SLR 514
  • [2023] 4 SLR 630
UK (6)
  • [1905] 1 Ch 76
  • [1911] 1 Ch 502
  • [1916] 2 Ch 417
  • [1948] 1 Ch 465
  • [2011] EWHC 485
  • [2018] EWHC 785
AU (2)
  • [2012] SASC 28
  • [2019] FCA 1521

Related cases

Other Singapore judgments on the same subject, most closely matched first.

Referenced in

Statutes interpreted in this judgment

Read the full judgment

The judgment itself is on the official Singapore Courts portal.

Read on eLitigation

Source: eLitigation ([2024] SGHC 203)

This page sets out what the court decided, for learning. It is information, not legal advice. Disclaimer